What You Need to Know If You Decide to Stay
Six years ago, it was my great misfortune to find myself in need of the advice from the various members of this unfortunate club. I wish I could say that I followed every piece of advice that the folks here gave me but I can say that the advice I received here was invaluable. However, that throwaway account is long since lost in the digital ether and as much as I wish I could offer an individual, personalized thank you to every single person who offered their help, insight, and advice, that isn't possible. In my mind, the next best thing is paying it forward. What follows is my best attempt to do so.
NB: I write from my own perspective--namely, the perspective of a betrayed husband--and thus all pronouns referring to the unfaithful spouse are feminine.
In the immediate aftermath of an affair (or affairs) being discovered or disclosed, one of the earliest and most persistent questions a betrayed spouse will ask themselves is "Should I Stay or Should I Go?" (cue Mick Jones' vocals). I cannot tell you what to do. That's a decision that you and you alone have to make. What I can do is tell you what you need to know if you decide to stay:
If you stay, you need to know that the odds are stacked against you. From what I've seen and from what I've lived, in order to find a reconciliation that ends in a genuinely better marriage you'll have to start by searching for a chupacabra and then hope you trip over a unicorn and land on a "our marriage is better than ever" reconciliation. The odds are much stronger that if you do manage to stay together, you'll spend the rest of the marriage walking with a metaphorical limp. Those brief, passing touches? The casual way your wife leaned into you? They're going to make you flinch for months and then they disappear entirely.
If you stay, you need to know that you'll never get the marriage you were promised the day you said your vows. That marriage was taken out behind the barn and put down like a lame horse. You also need to know that the future you could have had together the day you exchanged vows is impossible now. Your wife's affair has changed all of that. You will never be able to love her as recklessly and as surely as you did before you found out what she was doing behind your back.
If you stay, you'll insist on a full disclosure. But the reality is that you never be certain that you know the whole truth of what happened. You'll remind yourself constantly that human memory is frail at best and that there's absolutely nothing you can do about memory fading as time passes. But every single time you hear "I don't remember" you'll never be able to lose sight of just how convenient that is for her. She gets to not remember while you get to never forget.
If you stay, you need to know that your sleep is never going to be quite right again. The nightmares will be even more intense than the nightmares you had after OEF1; in fact, on the bad nights your nightmares will be a jumble of images: firefights in the Shah-i-Kot intercut with your wife having sex with her fifteen different affair partners. But even apart from the nightmares and the sleep disturbances--even on the nights you actually get decent sleep--you're going to wake up angry (to one degree or another).
If you stay, you'll have to listen to her rewrite the history of the marriage when she speaks to your friends and family. And you stand by and grit your teeth and say nothing because you're both too good-hearted to expose her to shame and ridicule and because you're buried in your own shame. You're reputation will take a potentially unrecoverable hit while hers stays unaffected.
If you stay, you're never going to hear her take the slightest responsibility for the way her affairs devastated your future. All the work you did to get two Master's degrees and a Ph.D? The hundreds of hours studying for licensure and ordination, the preparation to stand on the floor of a presbytery meeting and survive a floor exam in theology that took five-and-a-half hours? All of that is meaningless now. There isn't a church anywhere in your end of the Christian spectrum that will touch you with a ten-foot pole and your degrees are meaningless in a secular job market.
If you stay, you will figure out most of your triggers eventually--her car, her hairdryer, her North Face jacket, her watch--and so many of them will be unexpected. The tools you've spent hundreds of dollars and months learning to implement in IC will help but then one night she'll get home late from work and you'll see her standing on the front porch, framed by the window in your front door and it will hit you: she's a trigger too.
If you stay, you need to know that even after five years, full disclosure, her putting in time with an IC, you putting in time with an IC, and both of you putting in time with a MC, you're still going to find yourself waking up in the middle of the night and wondering how long it will be until she has the next affair. At other times you'll be overwhelmed with the suspicion that something is off and you'll find yourself in the floor having a panic attack.
If you stay, she'll come with you to the diagnostic assessment where you're diagnosed with autism at forty-two years-old; then you'll hear her blame her affairs on your autism during a marriage counseling session and you'll watch, horrified, as the marriage counselor asks you how you think your autism contributed to your wife's affair. And after five years of effort, thousands of dollars, and a strict accounting of all of your losses, you'll walk away and have to live with being seen as the bad guy.
I'm not trying to convince you to walk away from your marriage and I'm quite obviously not anti-reconciliation if I put in five years of work trying to make the marriage work. As a betrayed spouse, you and only you are in a position to do the hard calculus and decide whether to pursue reconciliation or to pursue divorce. Whichever one you choose, I want you to know that I'm in your corner. If you decide to stay, I hope you get the incredible, reconciled marriage that all of us dream(ed) of. If you go, I hope your freedom is as liberating and restorative as you dream.
Leaving is hard.
Staying is hard.
But you need to know that if you stay, this is one possible outcome.
Many thanks to all of you who helped and supported me along the way. I think y'all are pretty damned awesome.