r/Roofing

Image 1 — 72000$ for roof replacement
Image 2 — 72000$ for roof replacement
Image 3 — 72000$ for roof replacement
Image 4 — 72000$ for roof replacement
Image 5 — 72000$ for roof replacement
Image 6 — 72000$ for roof replacement
▲ 25 r/Roofing

72000$ for roof replacement

We live in DFW area, recently requested a roofing company for quote. We have received this. I feel this is very high but would like to get some input. Thanks

u/nallabob — 5 hours ago
▲ 15 r/Roofing

$70,000 estimate from a Roofing company- what’s reasonable?

My husband and I live in upstate NY. Our roof is large, around 3000sq ft and about 30 years old. We know we’ll be spending some money on it, but never expected dude guy to pull up with a full presentation and an immediate RIGHT NOW deal for $70,000. We basically threw him out when he started bs-ing my husband how his wife should be present for this amazing conversation (as I was fighting for my life with our toddler), but are now wondering what a reasonable quote would actually look like.

Originally we wanted metal, but are now thinking we’re more in a price range for a regular shingle. Our roof is not too complicated but there are some questionable areas to address. I just wanted to see if we acted too fast with Erie or if our guts were correct to move away from them. The guy just seemed super sketchy, idk.

reddit.com
u/OwlStrikeHunting — 7 hours ago
▲ 2 r/homeowners+1 crossposts

PVC or Metal Wrapped Wood?

Over the past several weeks, I had leaking in my 99-yr-old house and had a couple roofers out to provide me with quotes. We discovered the leaks are most likely coming from the third floor dormer. The wood is rotted out underneath the metal. I don’t know when it was last replaced but it’s at least 20-years old. The dormer is in the back of the house so I’m not overly concerned about appearances.

One roofer is suggesting pvc and the other metal wrapped wood. Both have their reasoning and think their way is best. What are your suggestions/experiences?

reddit.com
u/Remote_Shopping_6576 — 2 hours ago

First time roofing DIY

Started redoing my patio flat roof, been kind of fun, expensive but cheaper than paying for labor. Replacing wood at the moment and then doing roofing felt and liberty cap, and new flashing for than likely.

u/_e2t — 2 hours ago

What is this shingle?

I thought it was Atlas Stormaster at first, but I can’t find the exact color match?

u/RoarVanish — 4 hours ago

Paint or something else?

We just had our roof replaced and this bit is unfinished. It looks like it was previously painted, so I cleaned it up a bit and gave a light sand. Is a section like this normally just painted or should I do something else?

u/Ok-Champion-9421 — 2 hours ago
▲ 4 r/Carpentry+1 crossposts

Skylight Removal, framing okay?

I’m removing an existing skylight that is about 31” x 31”. I’d like to restore the structure to be able to reinstate the clay tile roof above. All rafters are 2x6. The current skylight interrupts one rafter and the original builders in 1988 installed a header on either side. I would like to do Option A or Option B but would like a second opinion to see if I’m on the right track. Please see 2nd picture for existing and proposed options.

I will use Simpson Strong Tie hangers with 1.5” and 2.5” SD screws as required but I can’t seem to find one that lets me do Option A, would Option B be okay?

Any and all criticism welcome.

u/PaperweightCoaster — 9 hours ago

Which Shingles should I get

In the Midwest I have three choices between BP-Mystique 42 Certinteed- landmark and Owens Corning- Duration. These are the three shingles I have to choose from I’m sure there are better options but that would be an upcharge to use and I’m just not in the spot to pay anything extra at the moment. Between these three shingles which should I use.

reddit.com
u/Accurate_Range7825 — 3 hours ago

Shingle Identification Help

I could use some assistance with shingles identification here. All the shingles are wet as well making the color a little darker.

I don’t know how some of y’all do it just picking out brands so easy from only one bad picture of the top. Any tips so I don’t have to ask and can find out myself?

Cheers

u/ButtonDownMountain — 6 hours ago

Moving skylights?

I'm in CT and am re-doing my roof. I'm considering moving my skylights from the west to the east side of my roof. I like how they brighten up the room, but the direct light in the mid-afternoon is too much and it can overheat the room. Moving them seem like I will get less direct light, but still benefit from the indirect light. Am I missing something that I will end up regretting if I move them?

u/gelkins4 — 12 hours ago

Having my roof replaced. What should I look for?

we are under contract for a new asphalt roof, new decking on part of the house, as well as new gutters.

I'll be home for part of the day that they're working, so I can watch the procedure. I have never had a roof installed, as I'm a first-time homeowner, and only have lived here for about 6 years.

what should I look for while they're working?

reddit.com
u/folkheroine — 3 hours ago
▲ 1 r/Roofing+1 crossposts

Roofing contractors: what’s your CLOSE RATE on inbound calls?

Genuine question — I’ve been digging into roofing sales lately and I’m seeing a massive gap between companies.

Some are closing 37–52% of inbound calls…

Others are barely hitting 11–16%.

So I’m curious:

What’s your average close rate from inbound calls?

Who’s answering the phone? (you, office staff, sales rep?)

How fast are you picking up / calling back missed calls?

From what I’ve seen, speed + first impression seems to matter way more than most people think.

Would love to hear real numbers (even rough estimates).

reddit.com
u/alom11 — 4 hours ago

Roof Repair Questions

I recently purchased a house knowing it needed some work. Just found out the roof is leaking, and think I know where. Thoughts on how to fix this?

u/mrpicachu — 6 hours ago

Normal for EPDM roof?

Had an EPDM membrane installed on the lower sloping part of our roof when the roof was replaced in August 2025. Was doing yard cleanup today and noticed some bubbling/warping/blistering where it appears that the membrane is no longer tightly bound to the structure. Is this just a cosmetic issue or something to call the company about to get fixed under their warranty?

u/thatsashameagain — 4 hours ago
▲ 3 r/Roofing+1 crossposts

Anyone familiar with this company?

Looking to start subbing for them but wanna feel them out more first but haven't been able to find much online review wise. Anyone had experience with them in any aspect? Here's their website

u/yeetinator3221 — 10 hours ago

Valley shingle install: correct?

Just had my house re-roofed and was checking out some photos provided by the contractor. I’m not 100% certain on the best method to shingle a valley. Does this look proper? My only concern was that on the right side of the valley in the second photo it looks like some shingles are a bit raised. Does this look like it’ll let water underneath? We have ice and water shield installed under but I don’t want to rely on that. Thanks!

u/ComfortLow9436 — 22 hours ago

Shingle quality- Please advise on which to select.

I am just looking for some input. I am in the Toronto area in Canada and have a quote to re-roof with one supplier using GAF Timberline HDZ and they will provide a 50 year transferable warranty. Their quote is about 30% more than a 2nd quote for IKO Dynasty with a 15 year warranty. I probably will not be in the house in 20 years. Both are experienced long term roofing companies. Any comments on pros and cons on each approach.

reddit.com
u/Yazzzaa — 5 hours ago

How is it Looking?

I’m not home for this install so relying on pics from contractor. Install looking okay?

u/Overall_Recording_45 — 15 hours ago
Week