Need Advice From Anyone With Academic or Media Publishing Experience
I’m writing a long form essay about late stage capitalism. I won’t go into great detail about the text online. My credentials are that I’m a fourth year Public Finance major, which is a bachelor’s degree focused on government budgets, administrative law, policymaking, the public sector, taxation, and related fields. I'm planning on getting a journalism or political science masters after my degree.
I started this project about a month ago and spoke to a professor about it, though he is not from my university. My original plan was to publish it as a research paper through open access at either University of Cambridge or University of Oxford, since my university is part of EKUAL, which covers open access publication fees once a paper is accepted.
The professor has published papers in Q1 journals himself. He said he liked my topic and that I seem genuinely passionate about it, but from his own experience he explained that academic publishing has many unwritten rules. Even if the paper were excellent, reviewers would still see my Google Scholar profile, notice that I am still an undergraduate student with no prior publications, and likely not take the submission seriously enough to fully review it.
Honestly, that makes sense. Editors often only have a short amount of time to decide whether to reject or move a paper forward. I also have no real experience writing a formal research paper, and I do not yet know how to support my arguments through econometrics or statistical analysis.
Yet I know the point I’m making is important, and I have only found a handful of sources online related to this topic across English, Turkish, and German results combined. None of them approach the topic in a fully integrated way, as they each treat it from only a single angle, which is understandable given how recent and still developing the issue is. And that makes me want to publish even more.
This professor recommended that I try emerging journals instead but it's still unlikely I'll get a yes. Since then, I’ve also considered publishing through a newspaper or another form of media, but I honestly have no idea how to approach that.
I don’t know whether it would even be realistic to apply to a major newspaper without credentials in journalism, prior publishing experience, or anyone experienced enough to review my writing beforehand and tell me whether it is actually good enough.
I’m also unsure about the legal side of it. Do people simply send the manuscript or PDF directly with no formal protection over their work beforehand? I genuinely do not know how that process works.
If anyone here has experience with academic publishing, opinion journalism, or long form writing, I’d really appreciate advice in the comments or DMs.