was grunge ever really about the sound?
i’ve been thinking about how people talk about “grunge” as if it was a clearly defined sound, but the more i look into it the more it just feels like a really broad spectrum.
Bands that all get labeled as grunge can sound completely different from each other: alice in chains leans heavily into darker harmonies and a more introspective, almost nihilistic tone, while nirvana feels way more raw and punk-driven. Then you have soundgarden pushing into something more complex, almost metal-influenced.
And mad season kind of sits somewhere else entirely, more stripped down and atmospheric.
So instead of a single sound, it almost feels like different clusters that share a certain emotional space (tension, discomfort, introspection) but express it in very different ways.
Curious how others see it. Do you think grunge actually had a defined sound, or more a reaction to a specific time and place that later got grouped under one label?
![[FRESH] Squiggler - Hey Man You're the Best](https://external-preview.redd.it/pwgg-gsW56AopJdVp5NASFfEJV7RV_L8lAPNtEKX5UI.jpeg?width=140&height=105&auto=webp&s=4080f2bb71e090bc5674697e71c2000013b3fde3)





![[OC] Ashes On The Dancefloor - Filippo Canton (a journey through ruins and hope...)](https://external-preview.redd.it/rYAhpDqvNY4Tzq1mYOn4N38JqPf6dikl3Z1EJj4lRcA.jpeg?width=140&height=140&auto=webp&s=c5d4c888f6ef289bafe76b66a5c9f5958c2641d7)



![[OC] Jesse Stilettö - Jesse Stilettö](https://external-preview.redd.it/qorQ8Yl-03WLa4lYr5jm0YpBRyaXTOkMFqJ-2lALgCg.jpeg?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=138da2e71d1cc40e3cf561208f65a84b6539c03e)


![[OC] Scared of My Brother - Vitamins](https://external-preview.redd.it/VtlESibGH9wZZz8zzCCBHYWdhaEGQ9QEaYlvCpNNW9o.jpeg?width=140&height=140&auto=webp&s=4913517fe41386cb3acbd5e0c2eb5fcd10fb68f2)