CMV: If a friend group doesn’t truly value you as part of the group, it’s better to leave the entire circle instead of only cutting off the people who treated you badly.
​ I ended up talking to a girl on an online video chat site platform recently and somehow we got into a long conversation about friendships and social circles.
Her opinion was completely opposite to mine.
I said that if a group dynamic consistently makes you feel ignored, disrespected, left out, or like you matter less than everyone else, then eventually it’s healthier to walk away from the entire group, even if there are still 1-2 people there you individually get along with.
My reasoning was: those “good” friends still accept the group dynamic, staying usually means constantly being reminded where you stand, and over time you start tolerating subtle disrespect just to keep access to the few people you like.
But she argued that cutting everyone off is immature and emotionally impulsive. According to her, you should only distance yourself from the people who directly wronged you and keep the friendships that are still genuine. Her point was basically:
“Why lose good people just because the group itself sucks?”
And honestly, I couldn’t fully answer that.
So CMV. I need answers.