r/FFCommish

Hey everybody! I'm looking for a few longtime fantasy football commissioners (especially MFL or Sleeper leagues) to test a website I’ve been working on for the past 6 months.

It creates a digital trophy populated with your league’s past champions, winning (and losing) rosters, championship matchups, as well as a few fun smaller features.

Supports ESPN, Sleeper, MFL, and has manual entry for other platforms.

Would love some honest feedback from real leagues before I fully unleash it. Hit me up if you’re interested.

I always try to pitch something new/different every year to help keep the league from going stale. We added a trophy/belt a couple years ago, turned the league into a keeper league, other miscellaneous tweaks. Basically, what are you doing to keep your league exciting this year?

Obviously we are in peak off season but I'm already planning for the upcoming season. I've posted here before but what are you wackiest ways to determine draft order?

I always try to do an in person draft and get everyone together. We all drink a bit and have some challenges or contests and the winner always gets their choice of draft position. Then we draft right then and there on the same day. It's always a blast and a great way to kick off the season. I take pride in upping the ante each year. A few things we have done were a combine with different events, everyone orders a pizza from a different place and the winner is determined by which delivery arrives first, and royal rumble simulator on playstation where I designed a wrestler for each league member, among other things.

If you just like to draw out of a hat, good for you, but those aren't the suggestions I'm looking for. Something fun and competitive that might involve a drink or two is what I want to hear. Thanks in advance!

I run a large 99 team Redraft league and I’ve been using the 100 yard dash app for the draft order for all 9 Divisions

Has anyone developed something new or have fund something even better?

We're launching a new platform this fall and need 10 commissioners to beta test the platform before NFL kickoff. Paying $200 per commissioner upon completion.

What you'd be testing:

• Weekly fresh drafts under a salary cap
• Last-place entry gets eliminated each week
• Weekly winner earns Immunity (an elimination shield)
• Eliminated players win their way back in through Re-Entry
• Format tagline: Draft. Survive. Repeat.

The platform has run for 4 NFL seasons. We're testing new architecture and engagement flows ahead of public launch.

What we need from you:

• Run a private feeder league with 8 to 20 of your regulars
• Play through 4 weeks of preseason testing (Aug 8 to Sep 5)
• Submit weekly feedback on scoring, UX, and rules clarity
• One 30-minute exit call with the founder

What you get:

• $200 honorarium on completion
• Direct line to the founder during testing

Qualifications:

• You commish at least one fantasy football league
• Your league has run for 2+ seasons
• You and your players use mobile
• You have 4 to 6 hours to commit between Aug 8 and Sep 10

Drop a comment or DM if interested. First 10 qualified commissioners get spots.

If There Isn't A Rule Against Collusion, Then Is It A Legitimate Strategy?

View Poll

As you all know, it’s a thankless job. Hard to get new rules passed even though you have done the research, burnout from doing it forever, never winning due to commissioner’s curse, and a myriad of other reasons.

I’m in a 15-year league with a many of my best friends, but I know the league would disband if I didn’t commission it. But that shouldn’t be the only reason I’m doing it, and that’s where I feel like I’m at.

I find myself having a lot less fun playing fantasy football, caring less about making the league better, compiling my league’s stats, dreading getting everything ready for our draft, etc. I pride myself on putting out a great product, but my drive is waning. The NFL wanting to increase the season doesn’t make me anymore excited either.

How do you commissioners keep your fire burning?

And more importantly… why?

At the end of the day, what keeps you invested longer:
structure, stability, and consistency…
or creativity, surprises, and memorable moments?

Curious where people land on this — especially commissioners.

In this league, the commissioner put in the draft order two months ago. Afterwards a trade via two new guys occurred and one team left. The one that stayed kept the 1.1, Allen, and Chase in the trade. Since people left and new people entered the league, there are now holes in the draft order- the order of the first five picks are now not entered. I just looked and it appears that the draft order was supposed to be in the order of regular season finish. Now, the guy that traded for the 1.1 appears to now have traded for the 1.3.

Since I brought it up, the guy that traded for the “1.1” is having an uproar because I brought it up. He says that I’m “mad” because of the trade that was made and he should get the 1.1 no matter what.

What would you do as the commissioner? Would you give the 1.1 to the correct owner or would you give it to the guy who thought traded for the 1.1?

We do a weekly high score payout. The idea is simple, if the 2nd highest scoring team loses to the highest scoring team in a given week, then it's a "bad beat", and the weekly high payout is split between the two teams.

Thoughts?

What would make your Dynasty experience more true to life as far as strategy goes? Would it be some sort of insurance policy so if our number one pick pulls a hammy in week 2 it doesn't turn into our rebuild year, or maybe it would be less bench players to reward all the studying you did on every matchup during every family outing, over the summer? Tell us your thoughts...

Basically what the title implies. Would you allow two teams to bet a draft pick on NFL results.

Semi Hypothetical. Two league members are talking sh*t about each others pro teams. One suggested betting their 2027 3rd round pick on which team ends up with the better record. Let’s say Packers v Lions.

Obviously this would open up a larger can of worms where betting draft picks shouldn’t be allowed.

But in a vacuum would you be okay with two teams betting a draft pick against each other on the NFL.

Here’s a weird format idea I’ve been working on:
You start the season with:
8 roster spots

all starters
no bench
no waivers
no free agency

Every week, the league expands.
A new roster position gets unlocked and an expansion draft is held for available players.
BUT…

Fantasy standings don’t control the expansion.
A weekly NFL Pick’Em challenge does.
Each week, managers predict NFL game winners. Tiebreaker is Monday Night Football total points.
Whoever wins becomes the “Expansion Controller” for that week and gets to:
choose the expansion draft order

decide what roster slot gets added next

Examples: Bench spot

Regular bench spot or
FLEX
Superflex
IDP

So one week QBs are nearly worthless…
Then someone activates Superflex and suddenly quarterbacks become the most valuable asset in the league overnight.

And because waivers/free agency never open, every expansion draft becomes extremely important.
The whole format turns into:
adaptation

- market timing
- league politics
- ecosystem management

Managers aren’t just building teams.
They’re trying to survive an evolving league economy.

Hypothetically would you play in this?

I am using Sleeper and I am not a fan of their schedule randomizer. As it is currently, my 10-team league plays each team once Week 1-9. This is fine. However, starting Week 10, every team just plays the exact same schedule they had in Weeks 1-9 for the remaining weeks. To me, that is incredibly uninteresting.

I would like to spice up the schedule more by making it way more random. Maybe Team A plays Team C Week 1 and 3, for example. But, if anything, I would like Week 10 - Week 15 not to just be a copy of Week 1-9.

I want to make sure all teams play each other once, and no team plays another more than twice during the regular season.

Any tips or suggestions on how to accomplish this while still keeping things balanced and fair?

Sign up is free, 2 week free trial, and super cheap after that if you decide to continue using it!

Hello fellow commissioners!

When forming a league online with strangers, I’ve had issues keeping a league together. Many times it’ll take a few seasons to weed out bad apples of different flavors. The following is a list of what I usually run into:

- Toxic players that get dramatic
- Inactive players that don’t engage with the league
- Players only wanting to take over the free years and try to win it all then bailing

I wanted to see if other peeps have similar issues and what yall do to make sure online/public leagues with strangers are formed and stick together.

I am trying to evaluate trade success/failures for the last 10 years of my league. Is there any website or way to see trade value of a player on a particular week in the past?

I have been using FantasyPros to see what the player ranking was on a given week in the past (pre and post trade), but it doesn't do a very good job of accounting for positional importance.

Anyone have any ideas?

Finished 2nd last season, traded 26 and 28 1st and 2nd round picks for Burrow and Bucky. So I expect to have a chance at the championship again.(being optimistic) My question is, is this pick more valuable now not knowing where it will finish or mid season? And what would a 27 1st be able to bring back? Looking for a starter.

Current roster
Williams
Burrow

Gibbs
Jeanty
Bucky
JCM

Pickens
Higgins
Burden
Pitts