Creating a tracking plan from a website structure humbled me
​
Creating a measurement/tracking plan from a website’s structure sounded easy until I actually had to do it. At first, I approached it like a neat technical task. I thought I could open the website, go through the menu, list the pages, identify the buttons, and decide what should become an event in GA4. It felt like something that should follow a straight line. But the more I looked at the site, the more it reminded me of trying to understand someone’s life by looking only at the rooms in their house. You can see the kitchen, the bedroom, the sitting room, and the hallway, but that does not tell you where people actually spend time, where they argue, where they make decisions, or where they quietly give up. That was the problem with the website too. The structure showed me the pages, but it did not show me the real behavior behind them. Some pages looked important because they were prominent in the navigation, but they did not seem to carry much real decision-making weight. Other pages were buried deep in the site, yet they had actions that clearly mattered: form submissions, quote requests, phone clicks, downloads, and contact attempts. Even the buttons were confusing. The same “Contact Us” button could mean different things depending on where the visitor clicked it. On one page, it felt like a serious buying signal. On another, it felt like someone was lost and needed help. That was where my frustration came in. I started realizing that tracking everything would not solve the problem. It would only create a bigger one. A tracking plan can look impressive because it has many events, but if those events do not answer meaningful business questions, they become noise. You end up with reports full of activity but very little understanding.
The biggest lesson for me was this: a website structure is not the same thing as a customer journey. A page is not just a page. A pricing page may represent comparison, doubt, budget concerns, or readiness to buy. A form submission may be a strong lead, but a form start that never gets completed may reveal friction. A download may look like engagement, but it may not mean much unless you know what the user was trying to accomplish. By the end, I stopped asking, “Can this be tracked?” and started asking, “Would knowing this help us make a better decision?” That changed everything. It made me see a tracking plan less like a technical checklist and more like a story about human behavior. People come to a website with questions, fears, urgency, curiosity, confusion, and sometimes frustration. A good tracking plan should help us understand those moments, not just count clicks. I’m curious how others handle this. When you create a tracking plan, do you begin with the website structure, the business goals, the funnel, or the actual user’s experience? And how do you personally decide when tracking becomes useful insight versus just analytics clutter?