What privileges to all trans men inherently have over all trans women? Honest question, no infighting.
White pre-everything trans man here. I highly prefer trans women & transfems reply to this post, I need to properly hear their personal experiences and thoughts about this topic.
Aside from the bioessentialist malgendering and name calling (theyfab, birthdayboy etc) that's being directed to trans men recently, there's been a lot of general hostility towards transmascs from just about anybody in the queer community, at least from what I've seen on Twitter. And as much as Twitter is a cesspool on its own, there are still real human users who still carry over their beliefs into real life, so I believe this discussion is still worth having. And don't get me wrong, I'm more than happy to complain about the many problems within the transmasc side (primarily within white transmascs) such as the masculinizing demonization of trans women and the questionable artistic depiction of transfems, but I feel the discourse has come to the point of outright denying any oppression trans men still face in the real world. Still, it's making me question a lot of things about the transmasc identity and if I'm missing a lot of things.
I was always under the impression that trans men and trans women were of different but equal oppression under the white cismasc system, but there are so many who argue that trans men inherently have more power over trans women, no matter if they're of color or non-passing or poor or disabled. An example I've seen is that they're more capable of securing housing thanks to "AFAB only" spaces whether they're passing or not, and that AMAB housing is completely awful in comparison. Aside from this, I genuinely can't tell if there's something else I'm ignoring or missing from the transmasc side, especially because, for as long as I don't pass and for as long as the government and my doctors know my birth sex, I will still be a victim of systemic misogyny and be at a great risk of femicide and sexist abuse, so that shapes a lot of how I go about my life.
Is it also that stealth cismasc-passing trans men have more social privilege over trans women - even when keeping intersectionality into account (race, disability, economic class etc) - that makes the entire transmasc identity inherently more privileged than the transfem identity? I genuinely do want to keep holding myself and my peers accountable for any remaining transmisogynistic biases we express, but I have to be honest in that it's becoming disheartening because of how much our transmasc struggles are becoming silenced yet again, even if it wasn't intended. I don't know what to feel other than I'm lost and overwhelmed, and I really need a proper discussion about this.
Once again, I highly prefer the input of trans women & transfems. If any transmasc is to reply, then I expect zero infighting or belittling from either side in the comments.
Edit: I'm at awe of the responses I already got, and I'm genuinely starting to realize I've been getting too used to an environment that's even more toxic than I thought it already was (no duh), I thought I was taking the proper precautions but I actually wasn't. I have a lot to think about regarding my beliefs, and I'm genuinely very thankful for the reminders I've been given. Holy shit.