Option A: 2019 540i xDrive with 61k miles, but has almost no service history records, 3 owners, and is being sold at an official off-brand dealer (i.e. a non BMW dealer but an official comparable make dealer) going for $25.1k
Option B: 2019 540i xDrive with 91k miles, but has extensive service history records (was always serviced extensively at the official BMW dealer that it’s being sold at, has two owners on CarFax but was the scenario where the original owner leased it & then bought it out after the lease, is being sold at an official BMW dealer (exact same BMW dealer where it was exclusively serviced its entire life), going for $22.2k.
I can post or DM links to anyone who wants to see the exact listings, but they are both similarly optioned in the sense that they have both have the Harmon Kardon sound system, heads-up display, ambient lighting, wireless CarPlay, anthracite headliner, etc.
What do we think?