r/TheMarvelousMrsMaisel

Just finished season 2 for the first time! Here are my thoughts so far…

Just finished season 2 for the first time! Here are my thoughts so far…

- My love for Susie has gone way up! I mean, she handled Harry Drake’s two guys very well with her street smarts. Also, now I get her bitterness. I mean, she has a horrible brother and brother-in-law. Her sister is nice though. She’s a great manager to Midge. Supportive. With tough love. Even with Midge’s high maintenance and self-absorbance at times. Now, I don’t know if she’ll take that offer from Sophie Lennon. But then again, she’s very supportive of Midge. But I won’t be sure until I start season 3. And of course, her dry humor still kills!!

- I love Midge too, but she can be too self-involved at times. But I get it. Not all main characters are written to be fully likeable. In fact, I like characters with flaws. And I guess for Midge, it would totally make sense. Joel left her and cheated on her. Her dad is so narcissistic, science-oriented and fact-obsessed, and lacks empathy. Her mother is also pretty callous and just goes along with the gender norms. I get that’s where Midge’s behavior comes from, but at some point, she needs to take accountability. But still, I admire her ambition and courage. And still, her stand up kills! I also love her and Benjamin. Certainly better than Joel. Now, I don’t know if she’ll still go on that 6-month tour with Shy Baldwin or stick with her relationship with Benjamin, so I’m interested in how that plays out. What I was surprised about was the last scene of the season where she shares a kiss with Joel, but I’ll get into that when I discuss Joel. Anyway, still love Midge and root for her despite her flaws.

- I feel like Rose and Abe are fantastic characters, but I wouldn’t stand them in real life. I mean, after all, they truly are products of their time. Rose goes along with gender norms with just being a wife and mother and without a job. Abe is also very science-oriented and loves facts and lacks empathy. I did love their Paris storyline, and Abe has learned slowly empathy for Rose during that, and it shows when he didn’t want Midge to mention her stand up to Rose until the right time. Also, I do have to feel for Abe because of everything changing all of a sudden, with Midge being on stage doing stand-up at the Catskills (another storyline I loved), with Noah being in the CIA, him losing everything at Bell Labs, and so on. Even though Rose and Abe have annoyed me to no end at times, they’re still fantastically written characters.

- With Joel, I’m on the fence about. Of course, I hated him in season 1 for cheating on Midge and basically being a spoiled and entitled brat. In this season, he did show some redeeming qualities, like overworking and improving stuff at his father’s clothing business. He also has a conscience and feels miserable for himself and has regrets at least. Then again, in the season 2 finale, I don’t know how to feel about him because he was mad at Midge for showing his kids to Benjamin, but Midge said that that was accidental and Benjamin just showed up. And he also said that she left him even though it was the other way around. Also, Joel also kisses Midge at the end. I don’t know if Midge came there intentionally wanting to kiss and get together with Joel, but either way, she did cheat on Benjamin. But I don’t know if the kiss was 2-sided because from the looks of it, it did seem like Joel physically pulled her in for a kiss without her intending to. I feel like Midge just wanted to be with a friend and that Joel exploited that, but I won’t be sure until I start season 3. So, I don’t know how to feel about Joel, but I am mostly on the verge of still disliking him.

- Lenny Bruce NEEDS MORE SCREEN TIME!!!!!!!!

Favorite storylines and moments this season:

Paris

The Catskills

Susie befriending those two guys

Midge seeing Abe in the audience and still performing anxiously

Susie threatening Sophie Lennon

Abe in that romper (or whatever it was called)

Midge on that telethon

Abe approving Benjamin

*Basically any scene with Susie, Midge, and Abe*

Anyway, loving the show and can’t wait for season 3.

u/This-Evening2278 — 1 day ago

Trying to remember a scene/plotpoint

I was watching Hacks last night and I was thinking about other shows with woman comedians, and I remembered what I think was something that happened in Maisel but cannot figure it out. I remembered midge walking into a club/lounge/country club place and sitting down for a meeting that she thinks was a meeting but was actually someone who was trying to sleep with her and she had to push him off. I recall the colors teal, white and black being the primary colors. I think the couch was rounded and white. It was very swanky.

Any detail I said could be false because memory is fickle lol. Google is no help. It also could be hacks, red oaks, or GLOW, possibly but I really think it was Maisel. I just remember that the casting director was a creepy man and he was like attractive so you wouldn’t imagine he’d be a creep but he was.

reddit.com
u/devieous — 9 hours ago

What made you keep watching The marvelous Mrs. Maisel until the end?

I genuinely liked this series the first time I watched it. However, I wasn't able to finish it due to other life responsibilities. Can you help me have more reason to watch it? (Spoiler-free if possible)

reddit.com
u/WorkflowBuilder_ — 3 days ago

One of my favourite moments in the series is when Shirley is staying with Abe and Rose during Moishe’s health scare. they talk about if Rose goes before Abe and they go back and forth about all these things, but it ends with the poignant moment where Shirley says to Abe: “If Rose goes before you, I’ll be there for you.” And Abe looks at her and says “thank you”.

Usually these couples are at each other’s throats. But when it really comes down to it. They are always in each other’s corner. 🥹

reddit.com
u/Intelligent-Exit9562 — 9 days ago

I just finished the show today (binge watching it after surgery) and I don't even know how to feel right now LOL.

Being an expat NYer whose parents lived outside NYC during the 50s and 60s SO much of this hit home. The NY stereotypes and places were things I had grown up with when I was a kid there (mid 60s - mid 80s).

I found myself massively aggravated by nearly every character at one time or another. I rooted for them, I rooted against them. I wished the show would go on forever, I'm glad it didn't. I laughed, I cried, I wanted to throw things. It was massively triggering for me for some of the family dynamics and yet somehow healing to know I wasn't alone and that a lot of it was generational.

And it made me think about "entertainment" - maybe it's good sometimes to be challenged, to be triggered, to be irritated, to be made furious, to cry, to think, to be exhausted by a show, rather than just be "entertained".

It made my brain hurt, my sides hurt, my eyes leak, and made me want to cringe and throw things, often all at the same time. It had to have been very well done, to make me feel all that stuff.

reddit.com
u/Northern_Heart_0925 — 7 days ago

I'm looking for a midge and lenny fanfic that was on ao3 but I think it got deleted? It was set in the future where midge had a different manager and was alone. Lenny randomly shows upto her house and they reconnect. She fires her manager and makes up with lenny, ethan,esther and susie. She even runs into shy! I absolutely loved this fanfic and if anyone has it downloaded or know whether its published anywhere else I would really appreciate it!

reddit.com
u/lucy074 — 5 days ago

Unpopular opinion

Just started watchinf Marvelous Mrs Maisel , in the 3rd season currently. One character I cannot stand at all is Susie. The scenes with her are extremely painful to watch. The whole trope of I dont act like woman, the jokes about her lifestyle, her snoring, heavily exaggerated.

Always with the worst one-liners.

Its making the show annoying.

reddit.com
u/Striking-Glass351 — 14 days ago