r/SalsaSnobs

My Grandma’s Secret Salsa Recipe (That According to Her Will Make Anyone Who Eats It Fall in Love With You)

Growing up, my grandma used to claim this salsa had magic in it. She’d joke that anyone who tasted it would instantly fall in love with you. Now, she’s the most traditional, conservative Catholic Mexican woman I know, so she definitely wasn’t talking about brujería lol. But once she finally shared the secret and I started making it for friends, I realized she wasn’t kidding.

I made some for a cookout with my partner’s family recently, and my mother and father-in-law were OBSESSED!!! The entire family spent the afternoon trying to deconstruct the flavors and guess the secret ingredients, asking for the recipe over and over and over. It turns out Grandma was right: there’s just something about this blend that keeps everyone coming back for more.

Ingredients:

- Tomatillos (1 lb, approx. 8–9 medium husked and rinsed)

- Dried Chiles de Árbol (16 peppers)

- Garlic (6 cloves, peeled)

- Bolillo (⅓ of a loaf, sliced or torn into pieces)

- Oil (2 tablespoons of vegetable or neutral oil)

- Salt (To taste)

Her Steps:

  1. Heat the oil in a large skillet over medium heat. Add the tomatillos and chiles de árbol. Fry them together, stirring occasionally, until the tomatillos soften and develop charred spots and the chiles start making you cough a little and darken slightly.
  2. Add the garlic cloves and the piece of bolillo to the pan. Continue to stir and fry until the garlic is fragrant and the bread has turned a deep golden brown.
  3. Carefully transfer the fried ingredients (including any remaining oil from the pan) into a blender.
  4. Blend on high speed until the mixture is completely smooth and emulsified. The toasted bread will create a thick, velvety texture. But if the salsa is too dense, add a splash of water. Season with salt to taste.
  5. Transfer to a bowl and allow it to cool slightly before serving. The flavors will continue to develop as it sits!!

Edit: If too spicy and concentrated, add more water! Or alternatively, only use half of the original amount of chiles de árbol (8 chiles instead of 16) and replace the rest by using Guajillo peppers (2-3 chiles)! :]

reddit.com
u/na519 — 5 days ago
▲ 1.3k r/SalsaSnobs

My salsa roja got first place at my company’s salsa competition 🌶️

The suspense waiting for the results was killing me all day 😂

(Not pictured: guajillo chiles and garlic)

u/peezy_pleasy — 5 days ago

Salsa Taquera Roja

long I've wanted to make a salsa that would be my house standard for all things and in particular tacos. so I made this. I was aiming for something quite spicy, smooth and with a good smoky overtone.

150g canola oil

150g white onion (diced)

20g garlic (smashed cloves)

10g dried chile chipotle

10g chile morita

5g chile chiltepin

10g chile arbol

10g chile puya

15g chile guajillo

60g chile habanero

100g chile serrano

50g chile jalapeño

300g water

75g lime juice

10g cider vinegar

2g chicken bouillon powder

a generous pinch of mexican oregano

kosher salt to taste

*dried guajillo, morita, puya and chipotle chilies are weighed sans seeds

  1. seed the guajillo, morita, puya and chipotle chilies and tear into smaller pieces.

  2. char the habanero, jalapeño and serranos using a broiler, grill, gas burner or torch. cut into smaller pieces.

  3. heat the oil in a pan over medium heat. add all of the dried and fresh chilies, onion and garlic. cook, stirring often until the onions are slightly browned and the fresh chilies are softened.

  4. put mixture into a blender and add the water, vinegar, lime juice, oregano and chicken bouillon powder blend until very smooth. add more water to adjust viscosity as needed.

  5. season to liking with kosher salt.

u/WastelandWesley — 1 day ago

Give me all your chip recommendations! What do you guys prefer?

I’ve come to find that I like a nice thick chip. The Mission tortilla chips are pretty good. Also a big fan of blue corn.

Right now I’ve got a bag of La Cocina Josefina and I can’t stand how salty they are. There’s also like a million chip pieces in the bag but I probably just got unlucky there.

reddit.com
u/buddhamunche — 6 days ago

Salsa Verde without Tomatillos?

I have moved to Spain and can't seem to find fresh tomatillos. I can sometimes find canned tomatillos and fresh jalapeños, but they are expensive and more difficult to get. Does anyone have a recipe for salsa verde without tomatillos that tastes similar or am I doomed to a life without salsa verde?

reddit.com
u/riceandbeansa — 3 days ago

One of my favorite salsas to make- attempting to recreate the sauce from La Bamba in Midwest USA

It's technically a salsa but the consistency is more of a hot sauce. It can be dipped, but I really love to pour it over tacos or into burritos as you work your way down. I consider it garlic forward with the restaurant version quite spicy.

Recipe:

4 large tomatillos
2 Roma
18-30+ chile arbol (adjust to your heat preference)
8-12 garlic gloves
2 cups veg/chicken broth (or water)
1 packet Goya Sazon (with achiote) (close to 1 tbsp)
2 tsp salt
1 tsp MSG
1/2 tsp cumin powder
Cilantro (present, but not in high quantity ~ 1/2 cup)
Juice of 1 lime (optional)

  1. Use a good high heat pan and put on medium high. Briefly/lightly char the garlic and arbol. Then get a good char on the tomatillos/tomatoes.

  2. Meanwhile add broth, sazon, salt, msg and cumin to your pot and give it a stir. Add garlic, arbol, tomatillo/tomatoes once they are charred. Bring to a boil and reduce heat to medium and simmer for 10 minutes.

  3. Remove from heat and let cool. Add contents to a blender and blend well. Add cilantro, push down into the mix and pulse a few times.

  4. For best taste, let refrigerate for 6-12 hours

u/Gloomy_Mulberry7834 — 3 days ago

Xnipec

This is Rick Martinez’s xnipec recipe from his cookbook, Salsa Daddy. It’s a version of pico de gallo from the Yucatán made with tomatoes, habanero instead of green chile, and red onions instead of white with sour orange juice (or fresh orange juice plus lime juice)

u/Jackson_Lamb_829 — 6 days ago

Rich and smoky chipotle salsa, Oaxaca cheese, cilantro, cotija, and some griddled tortillas. Super easy to throw together and so killer. If you can’t score some Oaxaca, grab some string cheese and get some good sized pulls, they’re extremely similar.

I’ve made chipotle salsas before, but ended up grabbing a jar of La Fundidora Humo salsa. Easily one of the best jarred salsas I’ve ever had!

If you wanna make it, throw a cast iron in the oven, crank it to 400* and let them preheat together. Once it’s up to temp, pull it out of the oven, dump the jar of salsa in, unwrap a ball of Oaxaca cheese and throw it in there and back in the oven for ten minutes. Hit the broiler for a little extra extra, then top it with some cilantro and cotija and serve it with some griddled tortillas!

u/bonebreak69 — 10 days ago

Banda! Salsa ahumada! Que les parece?

Para acompañar los tacos de birria ahumada también

u/kr1681 — 4 days ago

Magic love salsa

I followed this recipe: https://www.reddit.com/r/SalsaSnobs/s/0yp6yfwEWV

With a few modifications:

(1) less spicy: used 6 chiles de árbol and 1 chile guajillo — it’s definitely still spicy

(2) added a bit of onion, since all my other salsa recipes include onion

(3) added some chicken bouillon powder

The result: really good! I’m definitely going to add this to my weekly salsa prep.

Thank you again for sharing this u/na519!

u/CormoranNeoTropical — 4 days ago
▲ 56 r/SalsaSnobs+1 crossposts

I made the habanero-mango jam I promised in my firecracker post habanero is a completely different animal than chipotle and I had to rethink everything

A few weeks ago I posted about my cherry chipotle firecracker jam and someone asked in the comments if I'd tried habanero-mango. I said I was thinking about it. A few people said they were curious. So I made it — and I want to report back properly because it went differently than I expected.

Recipe as promised!

Ingredients (makes ~4–5 half-pint jars):

2 cups fresh mango, finely diced

1½ cups fresh or canned pineapple, finely diced

1 habanero pepper, seeded and minced (wear gloves)

3 cups granulated sugar

3 tbsp lemon juice

1 pouch liquid pectin

Method: Combine mango, pineapple, habanero, and lemon juice in pot → cook on medium 5 minutes before anything else (deactivates bromelain in the pineapple — skipping this risks a soft set) → add sugar → bring to full rolling boil → add liquid pectin → hard boil exactly 1 minute → skim foam → ladle into sterilized jars at ¼" headspace → water bath 10 minutes.

Heat scale: 1 habanero seeded = bright medium heat. 1 habanero with seeds = hot. 2 habaneros = bring a friend and sign a waiver.

The bromelain tip is the most important line in this recipe. Cook the fruit first, before sugar and pectin. Five minutes on medium heat. That's all it takes.

Full write-up with heat guide, chipotle vs habanero comparison, and serving ideas: pineapple mango habanero jam

u/Epsiom6757 — 1 day ago

Fresh tomato’s vs canned

I’m trying to figure out where I went wrong. I made a salsa last week and I used canned diced tomatoes and canned stewed tomatoes. Other Ingredients included fresh cilantro, jalapeños, onion, garlic, lime, salt, and dried chilles. This salsa turned out great. Upon doing some research I was told that canned tomatoes are bad and real Mexicans use fresh tomato’s. I asked what kind and was told Roma and tomatillo so that’s what I bought. I did a couple Roma and a couple tomatillos and included the same other ingredients as before however, this salsa was very lacking! There was almost like no flavor. It tastes like nothing. I’m shocked. I don’t understand 😅

reddit.com
u/Plane_Yoghurt9600 — 5 days ago

The Great Salsa Racket

Why do store-bought salsas in Canada all taste like someone just dumped a can of tomatoes into a jar now?

Surely I'm not the only one who has noticed this...

The golden standard used to be Neal Brothers or Que Pasa. Now both just taste like a sugary tomato paste.

Same with the basic PC brand and Western Family options.

I basically only buy Old El Paso Restaurant Style now.

Still tastes like a proper salsa.

Salsa-lovers: Rise up against this tyranny!

reddit.com
u/ElonssMuskk — 2 days ago

Finally dialed it in. Gringo made, Suegra approved.

- 2 Tbsp oil (I used avocado because it's what I had on hand)

- 15 Chile de Arbol

- 2 guajillo (deseeded, deveined and destemmed)

- 3 roma tomatoes

- 1-2 Tbsp. white vinegar

- 1/4 Large onion

- 4 cloves garlic

- 1 Knorr de Pollo bouillion cube

- 1/2 Tbsp. Kosher Salt

- 1/2 tsp black pepper

- Pinch Mexican oregano. My pinches are like a 1/4 tsp though so...1/8-1/4 tsp?

- Just a skosh water for blending peppers and onions

Heat pan, add 1 tbsp oil. Fry garlic and onions until golden and charred. Garlic will get done first; add onions and garlic to blender and keep oil in pan.

Toast guajillo and arbol, stirring constantly until soft and fragrant. Don't burn or it'll just be bad bad. Add to blender with oil and a skosh of water, vinegar, salt, black pepper, knorr de Pollo. Blend the best you can.

Slice romas in half, add 1 tbsp oil to pan. Fry tomatoes cut side down first and flip. Fry until peeling/blistering. Add these to blender including oil.

Blend until smooth, enjoy.

u/CompetitionAlert1920 — 9 days ago

- 5 Roma tomatoes
- like a third of onion
- 4 Serranos
- 2 Jalapeños
- A Habanero
- 2 cloves of garlic

Toasted all of those until they got a little color then blended with 2 14 oz cans of fire roasted tomatoes. Also threw in some cilantro, chicken bouillon, and white vinegar. At the end I added a little water to thin it out.

Overall it’s very tasty. I do think it’s a little tomato forward and I’m not sure if it’s from the fresh tomatoes or the cans. I’d describe the heat as hotter than store hot but not like I need to take a break.

Will be tweaking the recipe going forward so stay tuned!

u/ZZwhaleZZ — 11 days ago

It comes on the Al pastor tacos I get. It’s garlicky, a little sweet, a little spicy. It’s also thicker than the rest of the salsas I’ve had from my taco place. It’s so good I could literally drink it. I looked in the recipe archive and while a lot of them looked close, none have a sweet ingredient. Sometimes the cashier’s call it “pineapple salsa” so I’m inclined to believe there may be pineapple in it.

these are tacos I made and put the salsa on, not what it normally comes on

u/irishbarbiee — 13 days ago