My (22F) boyfriend (21M) has begged for months for a cock sleeve, and I don't want it
Me and my boyfriend have a great sex life. I'm always satisfied. He's given me the best sex experience I've ever had. He has a long dick with aberage girth. He has many insecurities, one being his girth. I've joked about it lightheartedly, he has made jokes about me as well. Nothing crazy. I've never had a complaint about his girth or our sex in general. Neither has he.
He has begged on and off for months for me to let him use a cock sleeve on me. I've always said no, and has begged him to stop asking. I've explained how much it hurts that he's trying to force it on me. I feel like forcing me will take away pleasure.
I don't want to do it because (1) I don't want to be stretched by plastic (2) I don't want to be fucked by plastic, I want skin to skin (3) I love my boyfriends dick completely (4) this will feed into his insecurities if I enjoy it (5) he will hold it over my head, always bring it up, ask me a ton of questions on the experience to see if I enjoyed it more than I enjoy him
There have been times when we were long distance and he would beg me to use an object in the house that's bigger than he is. Afterwards, with a big grin, he would ask if it was better than him. It's either that turns him on, or he's insecure and wants clarification that something was better than him. Even though he begged for it.
He says he just wants to pleasure me more. He says he would only be insecure if I wanted it all the time. He says he wouldn't hold it against me or try it with someone else if I refuse. He used to say we could get one that was a sheath, but now he wants a full coverage one.
He went awhile without bringing it up after a long talk, but it has resurfaced. He is clearly obsessed and really wants this. After angrily discussing it for two days, I've given in. I'm afraid he will explore these fantasies with someone else if I continue to refuse. I'm afraid he'll never stop asking. I don't want to lose him or continue to make him unhappy.
Picking one out has made me uncomfortable. The thought of using one makes me uncomfortable. The thought of enjoying it makes me uncomfortable. The thought of not liking it makes me uncomfortable. The thought of his insecurities and 50 questions makes me uncomfortable. I just want to cry.
Do I need to be more open minded, and listen to him when he says he "just wants to pleasure me more"? Am I overrating by worrying about his insecurities? Do I need to worry about enjoying it and hurting his feelings? Will this destroy us?
TLDR; My boyfriend has begged me for months to let him use a cock sleeve even though I've begged him not to. I gave in because I want to make him happy. I feel unheard, humiliated, and used. Am I not being open minded enough?