Controversial opinion(?): We HAVE to stop with the "top X" suggestions!
Like "Give me your top 5", "top 10", etc.
Fragrances are highly subjective.
For example, think of your top 2 favorite colors. My favorite 2 colors are silver/grey and cobalt blue. What are the chances these are your top 2 colors? Very low. With fragrances, it's even lower, as there are about 40,000 profiles to choose from (and hundreds of thousands of variations).
So, advising someone to get a cobalt blue shirt just because you love it is misleading, but if someone already says "I love blue the best", then recommending a specific shirt that also has a very comfortable fabric (quality), can withstand 800 washes (performance), and has a complementing cut (mass appeal/versatility), is a good suggestion. But for that, you need to know the basic taste of the person who's asking.
So for people asking for advice, either know the general idea of what you like before you ask, or start exploring fragrances by smelling them for free at the store, and then get an idea of what you like. Blind buying based on other people's tastes is a horrible idea. The chances 2 people will have the same top 10 after they tried 500 is close to 0%.
And for people being asked for this advice, the best thing you can do to help is to ask for what they're looking for (or link them this post), then continue from there.
This "top X" trend came from influencers, who are just looking for clicks on their affiliated links!