I was pressured to write things down by my employer that will be used as legal evidence. Could I make a fairwork claim for coercion?
I looked on fairwork. The only fairwork claims that seems relevant is "undue pressure and influence claim" and "coercion claim". The undue pressure and influence claim focuses only on employment contracts, so that means I'm left with only applying for the coercion fairwork claim.
The situation is that I'm a college graduate working in a small independent business and the manager who has worked here for 20 years asked to have lunch with me. She walked me to the local Cafe 1 min walk away.
She put a blank piece of paper in front of me and told me to write negative things down about the other supervisor. I tried saying no. I tried making excuses like he's my supervisor. I also said he always talks about court, and the manager made a face like she was a bit concerned about the court part. And then she shook her head a few times and then slid the paper closer to me.
I picked up the pen and started writing things down. While I was writing things down, she said really terrible negative things about him. She talked about his parents, his parents medical conditions, his partner, she talked about how she thinks he is very lonely and insecure, she talked about the house he purchased in another town, she gave a lot of examples of what he did in the past 6 months at work, basically everything she knew about him. All of these things I didnt know about him and obviously, is none of my business, and yet she told me.
I tried to only say good things about him, but the manager kept shifting it towards negative things about him. She also had a A4 notebook open in front of her which I have figured out is her "gotcha book", where she writes down everything that happens in the business. For example, I read the first few sentences on the page it was opened to (even though I wasn't supposed to) and it said "Jessica went to the sister store on 4th May 2026 at 2pm" which sounds micromanaging and unnecessary. The manager was writing down notes i was saying to her.
Anyway, when I finished writing until the end of the A4 piece of blank paper she gave me, the manager took it away straight away and put it in her handbag.
I cried during the Cafe lunch as well because I didnt feel right.
The manager told me that my supervisor is going to get fired. Why would she tell me that and make me write negative things down about him to use against me and him, if he makes an unfair dismissal claim.
The only thing I wrote on that piece of a4 paper is "i dont want to write anything down" over and over again until I reached the bottom of the page. I also was able to take a photo of that piece of paper without her knowing I took a photo of it. I pretended I was texting someone, but I was actually taking a photo. I took a photo when I wrote three quarters of the page. I didnt take a photo of the page at the end of finishing writing the page, because she took it away.
So I reckon the manager would've gotten a shock when she looked at the page when she got home. Because she was expecting me to write negative things about him and instead I wrote "I dont want to write anything down".
In my coercion claim, I could write there was a power imbalance between me and the manager, no formal meeting, manager paid for the Cafe lunch, I didnt know i was going to have lunch with her that day, workplace investigation protocol wasnt followed, I didn't receive an email to notify me in advance there was going to be a lunch meeting, put on the spot, made to write things down when I didnt want to, tried saying no, the cctv would show me waving my hands trying to say no and the manager sliding a paper in front of me, the manager disclosed that the supervisor will get fired, and the manager said awful things about the supervisor during the entire lunch and took that paper away from me. The piece of paper also proves she wanted me to write things down and that I wrote i dont want to write anything down. For example, it is very weird i wrote that phrase for the entire page. This is a very weird situation.
After the lunch, the supervisor was also very worried and kept asking me about what happened at the 2 hour lunch, so basically i was hounded by the female manager at lunch and then again by the male supervisor after lunch. The manager told me to say if he asks, then to say the lunch was about my female issues, which it clearly wasnt.
If I make a coercion claim, I will probably be fired as well. This workplace has fired two other people (not including the supervisor) in the past 6 months. In fact, I will probably be fired in the next few weeks before my 12 week probation ends, since I didnt write down on the piece of paper what she wanted me to write.
I really liked this supervisor. I don't want to stab my supervisor behind the back.
Edit: if I make a coercion general protections fairwork claim and then get fired, then I need to make a dismissal general protections claim as well? Thats two separate fairwork claims. And then my supervisor is probably going to make his own dismissal general protections claim. So that is potentially 3 fairwork claims the employer needs to deal with.
Edit 2: I need therapy after this. And I hope no one else has to be pressured and put on the spot like I did. This place is in a remote rural town in the middle of nowhere.
Edit 3: i just realised. So I cant tell my supervisor anything that has happened to me? Because right now, my supervisor has made it clear that he thinks i said bad or negative things about him at the lunch with the manager when in fact that is not true. The manager is the one saying bad things about him and not me.