



My Classmates Said These Don’t Look Good — Honest Feedback on My Handmade Charms?
I recently started making handmade beaded charms for phones, bags, and keychains, and these are some of the first ones I made.
The reason I’m asking for honest opinions is because something happened in class today that made me overthink them a bit. We’re making handmade farewell gifts for seniors, and when I showed these, some classmates indirectly suggested that they “don’t look good,” “look too traditional,” or may not work as gifts. So now I genuinely want outside opinions instead of just sitting in my head about it 😅
Please be brutally honest:
Do these look sellable as phone charms, bag charms, or keychains?
Would adding extra charms/pearls/ribbons/metal pieces make them better?
What exactly should I improve — colors, bead type, shape, finishing, aesthetic, etc.?
What price range/budget usually works for handmade charms like these?
I’d really appreciate genuine feedback, whether positive or critical, because I actually want to improve and maybe sell handmade accessories in the future.