r/createaroster

Welcome to One Piece Pirate Fighters!

We will be building a roster for a One Piece 2D fighting game. 24 slots is actually fairly generous, but leaves us very little room.

Rules:

1. If you downvote, you are hereby lame

2. Only 2 suggestions per person per post

3. Top 2 make it in

4. Filler/movie characters are allowed!

5. Particular versions (eg. Pre time skip Straw Hats as an example) are allowed!

6. We will be operating under the assumption this game is pre-Elbaf but post-Egghead, so no Elbaf characters. Maybe as DLC.

7. If you don’t specify a version I will assume its the most up to date/widely seen version. For example, Luffy is post timeskip unless you specified otherwise. Likewise, Whitebeard would be based on Marineford as that is where he did the most stuff unless you specify otherwise (though to be fair young Whitebeard would likely be a skin)

Roster thus far:

1. Monkey D. Luffy

2. Roronoa Zoro

3. Nami

4. Vinsmoke Sanji

5. Usopp

6. Franky

7. Brook

8. Nico Robin

9. Tony Tony Chopper

10. Jinbe

11. Donquixote Doflamingo

12. Trafalgar D. Water Law

Concept: From a wheel a random series will be chosen to assemble a team of four. Marvel and DC are banned because of how large there franchises are.

Rules:

- If the series has one protagonist, they'll automatically be added, since Persona doesn't have just one it's up to the comments to choose

- The top commented character for each category is added

- Every team must have at least one male and female character

- Specify what category you want the character in

- You can suggest one character for each category, but put each suggestion as a separate comment

What is a lesser/More Obsure pick?:

- This definition changes and shifts depending on the series, for Persona it can be any character that didn't originate from Persona 3, 4, and 5

A bit over a year ago, I tried to create a Justice League of Gaming. We got a few done before people stopped commenting. Now, we're redoing the whole thing. New roster for the Justice League and all. Most thumbed up choice makes it in, regardless of which hero you are replacing. In the event of a tie, I pick whichever one I think is the better fit. Once the final day is done, I will include my own personal picks for each choice.

Remaining Heroes: Doctor Fate, Steel, Fire, Ice, Rocket Red

Welcome to Designed for Victory, here’s the rules:

1. The 2 comments with more upvotes will get added.
2. The fighters have to be fictional characters that were artificially created in-universe, like robots, clones or magic for example. Also the character doesn’t necessarily have to be evil.
3. If you explain how the character would fight and/or why it was created, you will get a bonus upvote.
4. No downvoting.
5. One suggestion per user in each post.
6. A maximum of 3 characters per franchise will be permitted.
7. Have fun.

Based on the comics.

Rules:

- Comment only 2 characters

- No downvoting!!!

- A extra upvote for if you give me an idea about how the character would play!!

- Only allow Aquaman related characters so no Batman or Superman or any member of the justice league.

Let make a good roster.

When it came to Day 14 the top 2 answers were the only ones that were submitted which were the Tower of Druaga and Fulltasia Castle from Valkyrie (I may or may not have butchered that one because I can't really find a picture of it but it was a suggestion made by someone else earlier. However, we're almost done now. Because I wanted to DLC characters (just characters not tracks). My plan is 2 characters from IPs that are already in the Base Roster and 2 new IPs so let's see how that goes.

Rules:

1. Character must be from a Bandai-Namco IP (I'm aware that they have published games for shows like Dragon Ball but those will not count. It has to be characters that they actually own)
2. Every series that gets in will have a max of 4 reps (for variety reasons)
3. The two characters that get the most upvotes wins

Rep counts (characters):
Tekken (2/4)
Pac-Man (2/4)
Soul Calibur (2/4)
Xenosaga (1/4)
Katamari (1/4)
Klonoa (1/4)
Taiko no Tatsujin (1/4)
Tales of... (2/4)
Digimon (2/4)
God Eater (1/4)
Galaga (1/4)
Wonder Momo (1/4)
Valkyrie (1/4)

Day 26 of Smash Factor has come and gone! As a couple judges comments would have mentioned yesterday was a bit of a weird day at first-The submission quality was great for the most part-There were a couple that could use improvements and another that DEFFO needed more of a case *Cough* *Cough* Mr Game and Watch *Cough* Cough* But we weren't really sold on any of the characters themselves-a lot of them we could definitely come back to for sure but they didn't really add anything that we felt was missing from the roster-Until Pythra got submitted that is. Pythra was almost a landslide sweep with the judges-funnily enough the one submission that stopped it from being a unanimous vote was JC's other submission of Rayman.

Pythra added a couple things that the roster needed-The first was a new Xenoblade Rep, we haven't had one since Day 3, and while there are other series that are in more dire need of an additional rep it was about time Xenoblade got its 2nd rep too. The other was that there aren't a lot of female fighters on the roster. We had 7 so far-9 counting Byleth and Inkling who are both a Male and Female fighter. So Pyra & Mythra added some much needed girl power to the roster! They're also just a great veteran pick in general so those reasons and more were why 4/5 of the judges decided to choose them as the most recent addition to the roster!

Now lets move onto the rules!

The rules for Smash Factor are pretty simple-Characters you submit must be eligible for Smash-They have to be Video Game Franchises and the character has to have appeared in a Video Game (E.g. no Android 21 from DBZ Fighterz and none of the Sonic Comic characters who've never appeared in a game).

Tell us IN DETAIL why we should pick your character! Even if it's a character that you think speaks for themselves on why they should be added imagine these are the characters auditioning to Sakurai trying to persuade him to add them to the game, we want to see you build a case for your character on why they deserve to be in Smash 6 and convince us that your choice is the one that were should go with here and now. We will very likely ignore any submission that doesn't have any/good enough reasoning in their submission in favor of someone whose made more of an argument for their pick. If you've noticed that your pick hasn't been chosen by any of the judges maybe see if you can make a stronger case for them when you resubmit them? The difference could be what pushes us to decide to pick your submission over someone else's.

You get 2 submissions per day! Put them in 2 different comments and give a separate argument for each but you are allowed to submit 2 characters every day for the roster!

Me and the rest of the Judges can't make any submissions, all we can do is discuss and vote on the characters you've all picked-Though we may decide on a Theme for a day if we feel like the roster is in desperate need of something or we may choose to skip a day/ choose a character between ourselves if there's Slim Pickens when it comes to the characters that are submitted.

That's everything from me so without further ado, let Day 27 of Smash Factor begin!

Annie joins the battle

Rules:

1. Daily and 1 character per day (best one gets in)

2. Don't have to necessarily be restaurant mascots; just anything related to food (Starbucks, Starkist Tuna, Pepsi, etc).

3. No downvoting or rude comments.

4. One character per brand (we don't need the entire population of McDonald Land flooding the roster).

5. Don't necessarily have to replace a Smash Bros character (unless you really want them to).

6. Have fun!

the battle for the music is blasting in, let make a roster themed about music characters throughout series!

rules:

- only 2 comments allowed

- no downvoting allowed

- the character have to have a big connection to music to be allowed

- a extra upvote if you give me a idea on how the character will play!

If any of the intros are out of character i apologize since i don’t have all the knowledge of every single series.

let make a good roster!

• The characters submitted must originate from Weekly Shonen Jump manga, and must follow the specific directions mentioned in the comment replying to this very same one
• There will not be a franchise system, so for example the Batman and Joker replacements do not need to be from the same series
• Each person will be able to submit one character each day
• Each day, two characters will be selected to win
• The characters replaced will follow the expected behavior of the character rather than the characters in Injustice. When we replace Superman, we're replacing classic Superman, not Injustice Superman
• This next thing is really important. Characters that fit the preferably requirements will NOT get any particular boost, other than winning ties in the chance one would occur. In other circumstances, the most upvoted character will win regardless of how many characteristics they meet
• No downvotes, this is to have fun
• Rules are subject to change

The characters we're replacing today are Cyborg and Lobo

Cyborg needs: A hero who is half-human half-machine. Preferably: if they have belonged to several groups across its life.

Lobo needs: A villain who is an experienced bounty hunter. Preferably: if they're considered by many people, both inside and outside their manga, as a character that creates excitement or hype

A Hero shooter whose classes are based on the equipped weapons.

The classes are:

FRONTLINER: short- and medium-range fighters, equipped with automatic or burst-fire long weapons, such as assault rifles, machine guns and submachine guns, or shotguns

DUELIST: medium-long range gunslingers, equipped with handguns

LONGSHOT: Masters of long-range precision, armed with sniper rifles, marksman rifles, bows or crossbows

RULES:

1. No downvote, If I discover a comment with a lower score it will receive an upvote bonus

2. Each user can give a maximum of three suggestions, divided into each of the three roles

3. Characters cannot be part of more than one role, if a character has a greater variety of weapons choose according to the most iconic one (or in general the type uses the most)

4. Bonus upvote if you include an abilities set and ultimate

5. Only fictional characters allowed

6. For each role, the character with the most upvotes will be included in the roster, in case of a tie I'll use the wheel of fortune

7. Seasonal content may be coming

8. Have fun

The regulation may be subject to change

RULES:

-Character with the most upvotes is added.

-No downvoting, of course. If you provide proof your submission was downvoted, you get +2 upvotes.

-No asking people to upvote your submission in return for upvoting their submissions. I’ve seen this done sometimes on this sub and I don’t like it.

-No characters already in DBD.

-No characters with especially bad controversies surrounding them (ex. Jeepers Creepers)

-Characters submitted don’t necessarily have to be from a horror series but should be at least horror adjacent (ex. King Boo from Luigi’s Mansion).

-Characters have to be able to work in DBD (ex. Christine is one of my favorite horror bad guys... but she’s also a car. Not a lot to work with there).

-Please do not submit real serial killers. Just don’t.

-Following up from the previous rule, submitting real people for survivors is fine, as long they’re not controversial figures and have a connection to horror (ex. Nicholas Cage is in the real DBD).

-If you come up with a power or perks for your character, you get a bonus +1 upvote.

-One per franchise for each roster

Maxed out franchises: Friday the 13th

More rules may be added if needed.

Welcome to *Sega Ultra Stars Tennis*, a sequel to Sega Superstars Tennis!

This game takes inspiration from Sonic Racing Crossworlds in pushing the boundaries in roster size and appealing to the fans.

RULES:

1. No downvoting

2. 1 team suggestion per person and one court suggestion, but put them in different messages.

3. This is strictly Sega owned characters only. This doesn’t mean just Sonic, but is also means the likes of Hatsune Miku is not allowed. Look up who Sega owns before commenting. Third parties may be DLC if this is popular.

4. The top voted court and 3 most voted characters will be added.

5. For now, we will try to avoid variants of existing characters. For example, if Sonic makes it in try to avoid Werehog Sonic as it is a bit boring to repeat. This may be changed if there is enough demand.

6. Including an Ultra Volley (a special move unique to each character when they hit the ball) is encouraged, as it will get you an upvote from me if I like it.

7. Try to avoid “or” suggestions. Suggesting both Team Sonic (Sonic, Tails, Knuckles) and Team Dark (Shadow, Rouge and Omega) in the same comment makes it hard to decide which gets counted for the roster.

Rules

You can comment anyone who has had a Symbiote

They can even be the same Symbiote but not the same person and they have to be atleast different than other hosts

Bonus upvote for a moveset

No downvoting!

Symbiotes:

Venom (Eddie Brock)

Carnage (Cletus Kasady)

Scream (Donna Diego)

Toxin (Rick Jones)

Silence (Andi Benton)

Agent Anti Venom (Flash Thompson)

Tantrum (Gwen Stacy)

Knull

It is time to wrap this soft reboot with the grand finale, Mortal Kombat Requiem!

Shao Kahn is victorious in Armageddon and is empowered with the power of Blaze. Now he organizes his forces to begin conquering and assimilating all the realms. In response, Geras, a Time Lord who oversees the various timelines. He assembles the surviving warriors of light to stand against Shao Kahn and his army once and for all...Prepare...for final battle!

Roster so far:
Scorpion - Shirai Ryu Grandmaster [ANTI SHAO]
Cassie Cage - Daughter of Johnny Cage & Sonya Blade [ANTI SHAO]
Takeda - Son of Kenshi, Shirai Ryu member [ANTI SHAO]
Shion - Son of Liu Kang and Kitana [ANTI SHAO]
Kung Jin - Son of Kung Lao and Li Mei [ANTI SHAO]
Jacqui Briggs - Daughter of Jax Briggs [ANTI SHAO]
Sub-Zero - Lin Kuei Grandmaster [ANTI SHAO]
Liu Kang - The revived former champion [ANTI SHAO]
Mirage - Servant of Geras (OC) [ANTI SHAO]
Rain - Illegitimate son of Argus and Taven and Daegon's half-brother [PRO SHAO]
Daegon - Leader of the Red Dragon and Brother of Taven [WILD CARD. wants revenge on Taven]
Chameleon - The saurian warrior now returned to his body after killing Onaga. [ANTI SHAO]
Geras - A Time Lord and overseer of the timelines [ANTI SHAO]
Taven - Son of Argus [ANTI SHAO]
Shang Tsung - Elite Outworld sorcerer, Liu Kang's nemesis [PRO SHAO]
Sareena - Former servant of Quan Chi, now allied with the Lin Kuei [ANTI SHAO]
Havik - Cleric of Chaos [PRO SHAO]
Jataaka - Former Netherrealm assassin, now joining Sareena to help Lin Kuei [ANTI SHAO]
Hydro - A former Tekunin cyborg, now freed from their control [ANTI SHAO]
Mavado - Lieutenant of Daegon's Red Dragon Clan [WILD CARD]
Reptile - General of Kotal Kahn's army [ANTI SHAO]
Raiden - God of Thunder (Sub Boss) [PRO SHAO, though under control of Shao Kahn]
Shao Kahn - The violent warlord now empowered with Blaze's powers (Final Boss, turns into Dark Kahn for Phase 2)

RULES:

1. Vote for a character of my Armageddon roster to be a survivor and pick a side for them, either the Anti-Shao forces or the Pro-Shao forces
2. NO DOWNVOTES
3. The top comment makes the roster and joins the final battle!

Thank you to u/Irregardlesslrreden for inspiring me to do a Golden Era Cartoon Roster

The rules are simple

Can only comment a cartoon character movie/show from between 1928-1969 aka the Golden Era of Cartoons

No downvoting

Can comment multiple times

Human-Human Fruit:

The Human-Human Fruit (Hito Hito no Mi) is a Zoan-type Devil Fruit eaten by Tony Tony Chopper in One Piece, allowing him to transform into a human or a human-reindeer hybrid. It grants human intelligence, speech, and the ability to stand upright to the user. It also offers several transformations called "points," such as Brain Point and Heavy Point.

Venom-Venom Fruit:

The Doku Doku no Mi (Venom-Venom Fruit) is a Paramecia-type Devil Fruit in One Piece eaten by Magellan, the former warden of Impel Down. It enables the user to create, control, and become immune to various poisons, turning them into a "Poison Human".

Dragon-Dragon Fruit Model: Brachiasaurus:

The Brachiosaurus fruit in One Piece is the Ryu Ryu no Mi, Model: Brachiosaurus (Dragon-Dragon Fruit, Model: Brachiosaurus). It is an Ancient Zoan-type Devil Fruit that allows the user to transform into a full or hybrid Brachiosaurus. It was eaten by Queen of the Beast Pirates.

Barrier-Barrier Fruit:

The Bari Bari no Mi (Barrier-Barrier Fruit) is a Paramecia-type Devil Fruit in One Piece that allows its user to create nearly indestructible, transparent barriers by crossing their fingers. Currently eaten by Bartolomeo, it enables immense defensive and offensive capabilities, such as shaping barriers into platforms or punching tools.

Time-Time Fruit:

The Toki Toki no Mi (Time-Time Fruit) is a Paramecia-type Devil Fruit in One Piece that allows the user to send themselves and others forward in time. Eaten by Kouzuki Toki, this ability can only travel to the future, making it impossible to return to the past, and it is commonly used to escape danger or jump decades ahead.

Tone-Tone Fruit:

The Oto Oto no Mi (Tone-Tone Fruit) is a Paramecia-type Devil Fruit used by Scratchmen Apoo that allows the user to transform parts of their body into musical instruments and play music with destructive, long-range effects. It creates sound-based attacks—such as slashes, explosions, and blunt force trauma—that harm anyone who hears the music.

Ox-Ox Fruit Model: Cow:

Minotaurus in One Piece is a Jailer Beast in Impel Down who ate an unnamed Zoan-type Devil Fruit that allows him to transform into a cow-human hybrid. He is a brutal, club-wielding character known for his high durability and relentless hunting speed.

Wring-Wring Fruit:

The Wring-Wring Fruit, known in Japanese as the Shibo Shibo no Mi, is a Paramecia-type Devil Fruit in One Piece that allows its user to dehydrate living beings and non-living things by "wringing" them out like laundry. It enables the user to become a Dehydration Human, draining liquid to store or consume.

Rules:

1. Suggest Nicktoons Characters for this Roster.
2. The chosen characters must have been created before December 7th, 2018
3. Nick Jr. Characters and other Non-Nicktoons Shows (Like Live Action Shows) will be our Third Parties.
4. No downvoting 
5. Have Fun. :)

Pok-ta-Pok is a Mayan ball game that is also a ritual. Learn more about the sport here. Players use hips to shoot the ball into a ring. I was thinking of adding a special power for each character, so as you comment the character to be added, add their image, and also explain their moveset. Green side is good guys and Red side is bad guys. Top comment of each team wins.

Everyone has been creating their own ''What if ??? created Smash'' so why not do it with Mario Kart, I thought...

But there are some ground rules that if you break, your comment won't count, and make sure to read carefully!

Rule 1 - Must be a Sonic character
Rule 2 - Must've appeared before ''March 17th 1995'' so you should check the character's debut before putting them down...

Also, the reason why it's March 17th 1995 instead of August 27th 1992 (Super Mario Kart's actual release) is because by then, Sonic the Hedgehog 2 hadn't released, so the game's only characters were Sonic & Robotnik, another reason is because MK64 & Super Circuit had the same roster, so I'm combining both into one, while the first game would release on the SEGA Saturn on the exact day Sonic Drift 2 released.

Also, in this alt. timeline, none of the Sonic Racing Games we actually got in this timeline would never exist, in pursuit of a giant series that is supposed to compete with Mario Kart.

Anyways, for our seventh character, we have Koopa Troopa.

So, which character should replace Koopa?

Which ever comment has the most upvotes would have their character on the roster!