Omg I just finished s1&2 for the 1st time and I am incredibly impressed with this show.
This is one of the best shows i have EVER seen. I enjoy the writing so much, especially the plot. It's really good how they write the plot so far, it seems that they really know why the audience loves this show. I love the twists and turns and how new storylines evolve naturally from existing storylines. I love all the action and intense physical drama, it's basically like watching an action thriller like Salt. I grew up on dutch House of Anubis (the original dutch version Het Huis Anubis) so I really dig the whole treasure / legends scavenger hunt thing!
Don't get me started on the dialogue, it's so natural and realistic. I really enjoy Ward and Rafe as villains. I love Sarah as a character too because I can relate so much to her avoidant attachment issues, and I love to see a female character with this on screen because usually it's the male characters with problems like that.
I like the addition of Cleo, I was thinking where has she gone so I like that she is back because I LOVE hearing her accent lol. At first I saw promotional photos of this other chick with the group and was like oh she's gonna be some new boring classmate they force into the group but it feels like a very natural addition.
The soundtrack is absolutely gorgeous so that makes the whole thing even more enjoyable! I love how they kept bringing back the north star motif and how it was symbolic of Sarah's character.
SPOILER WARNING:
I did however hate the ending with John B's dad still alive. All shows do this eventually but I would have liked them to have waited with this for like 3 more seasons. But whatever.
I'm scared because I'm gonna watch s3 now. I like that they are stuck on an island but I hope it's still somewhat enjoyable.
Recommendations for similar shows/movies:
Veronica Mars (2004) this show is VERY similar and SO GOOD! Don't sleep on this.
Revenge (2011)
Pretty Little Liars (2010) some similar characters and teen drama + good mystery/twists/turns/secrets
Het Huis Anubis (original House Of Anubis)
The O.C.
Rocket Power lol
Pirates of The Caribbean (2003): These movies are so similar. Pirates searching for treasures with a compass. Sarah = Elizabeth Swann, John B = Will Turner, Topper = James Norrington, JJ = Jack Sparrow lol
Resident Evil 7: Biohazard (videogame) set in the swamps/bayou of Louisiana reminds me of OBX too. Ward even says "Welcome to the family" like the iconic Jack Baker line. Rafe and Lucas are basically the same psychopathic/bad seed brother character. It's a survival game where Ethan goes into their huge mansion to save his girlfriend Mia. I feel like this game was an inspiration for sure.
Into The Blue (2005) The same but basically as a 2000s movie
Riviera (2017) soap opera / greek tragedy type show with a lot of action scenes in Europe. It's very different but you might like it