r/FromTVShow

I think the answer to this show has been simple and laid out from the very beginning. Save the kids.

This got misinterpreted throughout the show making Tabitha and Jade think they need to save kids from centuries ago. However, we have also been told that you can’t change a story once it’s been told. Doesn’t it make sense that maybe, just maybe, the solution all along has been for parents to protect and save their own children?

The writers said that the answers at the end go back to the beginning. The first thing we see in this show is a father choose to stay out at a bar leading to his daughter being killed. Boyd tells at him and says “A man protects his family!”

We later find out that Boyd left his family searching for answers which led to his wife going crazy and nearly killing his son.

The trend continues over and over. Jim and Tabitha constantly abandoning their kids to search for answers. The MIY told Sara to hill Ethan and she almost got away with it. Victor’s mom left him and his sister. Jade has been abandoned by his father. The examples go on and on.

There has to be a reason that Henry came back to this town… and so far he has been the ONLY parent to stick close to, and try to be there for his son above all else. i believe this will lead to their salvation.

Ethan has been right about literally everything since the show started… but his parents refused to listen and kept going off on their own journeys. Now Jim is dead and Tabitha has been warned that she is running out of time. Maybe if Tabitha tries to save her own children for once- it will lead to more information on how to get home.

The Man in Yellow is Azazel — the chief fallen angel from the Book of Enoch and the demon the Day of Atonement scapegoat is sent to in Leviticus 16. He's the angel who taught humanity forbidden knowledge, and he and his companions were punished for it. He's basically the fallen angel of Jewish apocalyptic tradition. KNOWLEDGE COMES WITH A COST is basically his life story, and goats and sacrifical rams are his call-sign.

Lilith is in the show too — Adam's first wife in Jewish folklore, who refused to submit to him, fled Eden, and became the original demon-queen and child-killer of the night. In some traditions she and Azazel are the original couple — she fled Eden to find a celestial lover, and was forced to sacrifice her children.

Here's the evidence on the show:

💃 John Griffin has said the MiY was inspired by a street dancer in a yellow suit he described as "dancing and moving with such joy, it looked like an angel trying out his body for the first time" — Griffin literally calling him an angel. https://youtu.be/-mLxQTgZj_E?t=3371

🐏 The hanging ram. (thanks Robert Saunders for pointing pointing out it is a ram not a goat).

https://preview.redd.it/p6yffnstjc0h1.png?width=2340&format=png&auto=webp&s=5ce993d5585ae3d35595a238ae4e42af5420a946

📖 Sophia quotes Genesis 22 — the Akedah, the binding of Isaac, where the ram appears caught in a thicket as Isaac's substitute

📖 Sophia quotes Joshua 7 — the Achan story, where one man's hidden sin causes the entire nation of Israel to suffer collective punishment. Azazel is the epitomy of collective punishment

🔮 The MiY is a shapeshifter (Sophia is just one of his disguises)

🪞 Mirrors all over the show — characters constantly looking in them. Azazel is specifically called out for teaching humanity to make mirrors.

https://preview.redd.it/usvrmrrwjc0h1.png?width=1392&format=png&auto=webp&s=e9661177587cb9940eae5046d78c56afe4bbf08a

🐐 Goats everywhere — Boyd finding the goat (in a drawing and in reality), Nathan's goats, Alma the goat.

Knowledge comes with a cost and goats are basically Azazel's call-sign

😇 Elgin literally talks about real real biblical angels — the terrifying multi-eyed kind, not Renaissance cherubs. "He calls the kimono wraith an angel directly.
Elgin: Remember now, there's a reason why angels say 'Fear not' when they saw someone. Even Gabriel was terrifying.
Julie: Wow. Look at you, Mr. Bible Study. 

🙃 The upside-down angel picture Ellis drew. At first, it's upright. Later, it has fallen upsidedown, hanging by a single pin.

https://preview.redd.it/6jle3ac2hc0h1.png?width=1600&format=png&auto=webp&s=3b8c4300f92394215ced2f8f99b1705cc9d05d30

🥩 MiY eating liver is reminscent of Prometheus's punishment for having his liver pecked out, another giver of forbidden knowledge punished by their god.

🚘 Numberplate beginning with AZ, I.E. Azazel.

https://preview.redd.it/ooo8zzr7qe0h1.png?width=1792&format=png&auto=webp&s=ec3865774e2529cc22cdf1d807a587cd6a23c805

Now here's why every one of these points to Azazel specifically:

The ram. Leviticus 16 is the only ritual in the Bible where a goat is sent to a named demon — Azazel — into the wilderness. It's literally where the word "scapegoat" comes from. The Akedah substitution-ram is the same sacrificial tradition. Sophia speaks the Akedah chapter, the show shows us a ram. Twice signed.

Collective punishment. 1 Enoch 10:7–8 says: "the whole earth has been corrupted by the works of Azazel." One angel's sin condemns all of humanity. That's exactly the theological mechanism of the Achan story Sophia just recited. She's quoting Azazel's signature.

The shapeshifter clue is the killer for me. In the Apocalypse of Abraham (a real Jewish apocryphal text), Azazel disguises himself as a bird and tries to interrupt Abraham's sacrifice. Just as Sophia's wrist is broken, so too is the bird's wing. Perhaps she transformed and followed them through the woods. 

https://preview.redd.it/1d3va1qq7k0h1.png?width=1182&format=png&auto=webp&s=56aeb9e3fcf87fe3faae89349f733efb84ac43cc

Mirrors are his. In 1 Enoch 8, Azazel taught humanity "the use of antimony for the eyes, the beautifying of eyelids, every kind of costly stone, all dyes, and the making of mirrors" — alongside weapons. Mirrors are literally one of the things he taught humanity. That's why everyone in this show is staring into them constantly.

Knowledge is his sin. Same passage in 1 Enoch 8 — Azazel as the teacher of forbidden knowledge. The MiY's whole vibe is "I'll tell you secrets you weren't meant to know."

The upside-down angel. 1 Enoch 10:4–6 — Raphael is told to bind Azazel hand and foot, cast him into darkness in the desert of Dudael, and place jagged rocks upon him. Face-down in the pit. The image is direct.

Elgin's "real biblical angels" comment tells us we're in 1 Enoch territory, not Sunday-school Christianity. And in 1 Enoch, Azazel is the chief Watcher, the most-named, the one who gets the worst punishment. He's the fallen angel of that tradition.

LILITH:

🦉 The owls. Eloise drew an orange owl coming out of a basket. Elgin's grandmother knitted owls. Scott McCord draws an orange owl at FROM conventions and has called one Victor's spirit animal in interviews. The word KN-OWL-EDG-E in the barn cuts out OWL.

https://preview.redd.it/m0nq0v72fc0h1.png?width=1300&format=png&auto=webp&s=7914c5c60a87839bee2d26af7cb3068c5fdec44e

https://preview.redd.it/7xcw47v3fc0h1.png?width=932&format=png&auto=webp&s=b30d9a4c0d1a3d15958721ecd6d69f9a0cbf0f45

https://preview.redd.it/81aevtb5fc0h1.png?width=996&format=png&auto=webp&s=bb5fd6f30c0b167325bc5a6d4c17fc9de5d20733

https://preview.redd.it/udgvh1dkhc0h1.png?width=750&format=png&auto=webp&s=2b68c92fe5bfd1bef625bab448b17b7b85993b9b

https://preview.redd.it/8neywx2lse0h1.png?width=1126&format=png&auto=webp&s=9e71459fe06c0a8749242dbbf582e80a2a0bc863

In Hebrew tradition (Isaiah 34:14), Lilith is translated as a "night monster" or "screech owl," placing her firmly as a creature that is awake while others sleep.

She is often associated with causing sleep disorders like insomnia, sleep deprivation, or sleep paralysis (the "night hag" or "night mare" visiting those sleeping alone).

7 Angels - 4 Cursed Humans

In fact there are signs that 7 fallen angels, once willing to teach humanity and later punished collectively for it, are taking possession of those on the show, waiting for characters to be suffused with sufficient emotion for them to make the transition, like pain, sadness, joy, or hope. It may even be some already have been, some overtly, some simply influenced, like Ethan, Donna, Kenny, Tilly, Boyd and Clara.

credit to source: https://www.reddit.com/r/FromSeries/comments/1igkxwt/angel_boyd/#lightbox

Indeed, with Jasper the doll, the nkondi-like totems, the moving scarecrows seen in the trailer, and the creation of a golem, it would seem these angels can possess objects, and perhaps even corpses, temporarily too, like demons. It's possible the monsters are the spirits of the original villagers possessing the corpses of the victims of Fromtown from the 50s and 60s. The magic involved likely involves bodily fluids, organs, hair and/or teeth.

I also believe there are 4 cursed humans reincarnating, though the 4 may reference some other set of beings, perhaps demons. There are also animals that these angels can transform into. Here's my map so far. You may have seen some of these symbols recurring on the show.

https://preview.redd.it/rrwalxhjic0h1.png?width=1522&format=png&auto=webp&s=396e96bf776fe9dc34397698887d1cfa18837821

Indeed, it is my belief that these angels have been living on the island of Newfoundland for much of their history, taking on the roles of the various mythical and religious figures in legends about mysterious islands, potentially including:

MOUNT ARRARAT & CANAAN
GREEK STROPHADES
CANAANITE OPHIR
EGYPTIAN PUNT
WELSH AVALON
IRISH PROMISED LAND
SINBAD'S ISLE
VIKING VINLAND
DANTE'S COMEDY
TEMPLAR/CATHAR ESTOTILAND
TUDOR NEWFOUNDLAND

This is why the show is layered with Greek, Norse, and other mythological references — these aren't red herrings, but rather cycles of the same seven angels appearing in different cultural costumes across history.

The Norse layer is important. Leif Erikson reached Newfoundland around 1000 AD and built a church there in Vinland. His sister Freydis was on a later expedition — famous for finding a beached whale, a conflict between christians and pagans, and a brutal massacre of her fellow Norse settlers. I think the Vikings are the original builders of the church we see in Fromland, and they're why Duluth was mentioned on the show — Duluth has the famous Leif Erikson ship replica in Leif Erikson Park. Ethan's book bag in Season 1 is covered in whales, which is Freydis-coded directly. The Vikings landed in Jellyfish Cove.

Then comes the 1498 layer: John Cabot's lost expedition, accompanied by a priest (Giovabnni Carbonariis), a barber/surgeon (unnamed) and a sherrif (Richard Amerike) who legend says named America (Mr Liu: "he want AMERICA name". His ship was called the Matthew, and Boyd's Cove is a real location in Newfoundland associated with early contact between European explorers and the Beothuk — the indigenous people of Newfoundland, known for painting their bodies red with ochre (which would explain a lot of the red imagery on the show, including the red-painted figures).

https://preview.redd.it/b0ba94uc8k0h1.png?width=418&format=png&auto=webp&s=776540f8466423f66452098dd735fdd7dfd4a8b1

In my reading, Abaddon takes on the role of a genuine Beothuk devil they genuinely called "The Man in Black" who lived by a lake with his sea-monster servant — likely portrayed in the show as a Newfoundland red lion's-mane jellyfish, the largest jellyfish in the world, native to those waters. Remember Boyd's line: "we called him Schmuckers because he loved Jelly."

The seven angels get trapped in a witch's bottle by a cunning folk woman from the expedition (you'll have noticed how many bottles appear throughout the show — and Pratt, the surname of several characters, means cunning in Middle English, alongside many other cunning-folk references). She is accused of being a witch using the Inquisition's book Malleus Maleficarum (Hammer of Witches), a world bestseller at the time (Khatri's bestseller references to Sarah) — which is why we see a hammer used as a torture implement on the show, and extras carrying hammers in background shots.

https://preview.redd.it/c6oo9ejl8k0h1.png?width=1566&format=png&auto=webp&s=173be029352c7d112016888dedd97ae2942b05b9

https://preview.redd.it/vju6y1hk8k0h1.png?width=880&format=png&auto=webp&s=fd5d5000e6945f27abe70971228c7fe535fee15d

Part of how she traps the angels is by challenging them to a game. Medieval tarot cards — and this is the tarot theory I've been developing since before Tilly ever pulled out a deck — alongside crokinole-style medieval board games. Game of Goose is the strongest match: its hazards correspond directly to the places in Fromland (the Well, the Hotel, the Maze, the Prison). Pachisi is another (the cross-shape, and 12 safe-castle tiles that mirror the talismans).

I suspect this game takes place right after the sacrifice.

More on the games here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/FromTVEpix/comments/1fxvi8v/imo_what_tilly_says_about_the_tarot_cards_are_the/

and here
https://youtu.be/nmtqYOSH1XI

I think Fatimas Golem will come to live andpeople realize they might have more influence over what happens in Fromville..

For example: Boyd really needed something to protect them, and suddenly the talismans appeared. Jim tells Ethan that the Lake of Tears from one of his books is real. And the whole concept of story walking, which also came from one of Ethan’s books, turns out to be real too. And then it's his sister, who already knew about the concept, who is actually able to do it.

What if the golem that Fatima builds actually works, and that’s how they realize they can shape the story themselves? Maybe previous residents did the same (without fully understanding it?), like with the scarecrows at the settlement.

In the cycle we’re watching, Sophia (MIY) knows that Julie is a story walker and that she’s trying to change things. Yet he doesn’t really interfere with her. The only time we’ve seen him directly provoke Julie was at the diner; other than that, he hasn’t made a move against her. I think the reason lies in the Man in Yellow’s belief that the story being told cannot be changed. He’s so confident that no matter how much Julie story walks, she still won’t be able to alter anything, because those stories have already been told and finished.

However, I still think that what Julie learns by visiting different stories could become important information for both her and the others. Because of that, I believe the Man in Yellow will eventually make a move against Julie in future episodes. And I think he may not do it directly, but instead by entering Sara’s mind and manipulating her into doing it for him.