r/CriticalThinkingIndia

We need higher interest rates to stop the outflows

considering the current state of India we need a bitter medicine for temporily fixing the problem . Thats comes as Higher interest rate . We got inflation to 8.5% last month. i am paying emis i love low Interest rates but here is the truth . Inflation is real issue .
higher interest rates will reduce the consumer spending.

my second recommendation is to go all in in Solar and EV .
also we should study how china is making natural gas from Coal as we have Coal and its cheaper . This natural gas should be focused on fertilisers only

we need a leader who can do harsh things but the right thing .

we need to ban all ICE vehicle sales immediately

we need to subsidize the induction stove bring induction stove culture

reddit.com
u/Nedunchelizan — 7 hours ago

The current govt doesn't want middle class to have wealth. Please watch and read.

The key problem with the current govt is that they don't want the middle class to have wealth. Wealth gives you a voice - it allows you to stand tall and speak up. So wealth goes into the hands of a few cronies and rest all people keep slipping down to poverty and below.

Then the govt will put you on their payroll - you'll be paid some paltry amount, a few kgs of ration and all you have to do is to shut up and vote for them. If you decide you don't want to - your vote itself would be nullified by SIR.

And I pity those who think they can escape this. This govt has systematically attacked the brains of its people. Cheap internet has made them docile - they'll show all vigour on the internet but avoid taking any action in reality.

The mind of youths have been corrupted - everything is religious, everything is offensive. Everyone has become some form of extreme, and there is non-existent logical thought. The people in power keep making comments deliberately to ensure that this stupidity can be maintained.

And the religious opium is there to skip any accountability. Just chant "Jai Shree Ram" or "Ganpati Bappa Morya". Or find some figure from history to bae all of it.

Education is becoming inaccessible every single day - for the poor, the schools are getting closed each day and for the middle class, they're getting costlier every year. Healthcare has become another such thing - where if you're a middle class without health insurance, you're one medical emergency away from bankruptcy. And the environmental degradation is a whole new debate.

Our people have also made enough bad name globally, so nobody's welcoming us with open hands anymore.

For those who still have some guts, who still can speak up and pose some opposition - they get the full force of govt machinery unleashed upon them. They'll be hounded by ED, CBI, courts, etc until they also become a cog in the wheel.

So what should one do now? How do we escape this? Those who know or understand it, I want to know your plans, and your thoughts around this? How do you plan to overcome all this gloominess?

Credits to the original creator - https://www.instagram.com/reel/DYRwgd6xI7J/

u/datadumbo — 21 hours ago

Dont get deflected.....Please read the entire post before forming opinion

People keep saying Modi was fully justified in ignoring Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng because an Indian PM doesn’t owe answers to foreign media.

And honestly, taken in isolation, that argument is fair. Accountability should primarily come from Indian citizens and Indian journalists.

But that’s exactly why this incident became a story in the first place.

If Modi regularly held open press conferences in India and answered unscripted questions from Indian reporters, then a foreign journalist being ignored in Norway would’ve been meaningless. Nobody would’ve cared.

The issue is that this pattern exists everywhere.

Twelve years as Prime Minister and still no proper unscripted press conferences. So when he walks away from a journalist abroad, it doesn’t come across as strength or sovereignty. It just looks like continuity.

Meanwhile, Norwegian PM Jonas Gahr Støre finished the joint statement and casually returned to speak with reporters. That’s simply normal democratic behavior.

Some people brought up the Epstein comparison, saying Indian journalists could similarly corner European leaders about uncomfortable subjects. Fair point. Many leaders probably would avoid those questions too.

But that doesn’t make avoidance admirable. “Other politicians also dodge scrutiny” isn’t much of a defense. It just lowers the standard for everyone.

Then came the conspiracy theories around Helle Lyng herself. Apparently she criticised Trump, wrote positively about Chinese EV companies like BYD, referred to China as a superpower, and discussed labour issues, therefore she must somehow be connected to the CCP.

But none of this is remotely unusual for a Scandinavian journalist.

Criticising Trump is mainstream across much of Europe. Calling China a superpower is just acknowledging reality. Writing about BYD outperforming Tesla is business reporting, not espionage. And labour rights are a central political issue in Nordic countries. People are acting like they uncovered an international intelligence operation because a journalist wrote about electric cars. Civilization truly is held together by tape and caffeine.

And even if someone believes all of those theories, the supposed “operation” still makes no sense. She shouted a single question while Modi was leaving the room. That required no elaborate coordination. Any journalist present could have done the same thing.

What the conspiracy narrative really does is shift attention away from the actual issue: why does the PM consistently avoid unscripted questioning altogether?

The same thing happened when Sabrina Siddiqui questioned Modi during the Biden visit. Instead of discussing the question itself, large sections of the discourse became focused on attacking the journalist personally.

That’s the larger pattern here.

The outrage repeatedly becomes the existence of uncomfortable questions rather than the absence of answers.

And that’s not confidence. It’s the opposite.

For people unfamiliar with the context: Modi is currently on a five-nation tour. During his Norway visit, he and Norwegian PM Jonas Gahr Støre delivered joint media statements. There was no Q&A session afterward. Støre later returned to interact with journalists. Modi left the venue, and as he was walking out, Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng called out: “Prime Minister Modi, why don’t you take questions from the freest press in the world?” Modi did not respond and continued walking. Lyng later clarified that she never actually expected him to answer.

u/Boss_withCrown2 — 1 day ago

Three coaches of Ujjaini Express derail near Rishikesh, no casualties

Three coaches of the Ujjaini Express derailed near the Khand Gaon area in Rishikesh on Monday night (May 19, 2026) when the train was being moved to the railway yard, officials said.

There were no passengers on board when the incident occurred around 9:40 p.m. close to the Yog Nagri railway station.

According to officials, the accident occurred when the train was passing through the yard area.

Railway sources said the locomotive collided with the buffer (dead end) located at the terminus of the shunting line, resulting in increased pressure on the coaches.

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/uttarakhand/three-coaches-of-ujjaini-express-derail-near-rishikesh-no-casualties/article70996584.ece

u/Snehith220 — 20 hours ago

Falling indian rupee reason.

In the last 18 months, Foreign Investors pulled out

almost $45 Billion from Indian equities because of the falling rupee, and a major reason is that India is nowhere in the global Al race, so they're betting on AI and chip companies in Japan, Korea, and Taiwan. In 2017, Narayana Murthy dismissed Al as hype at a time when global Al companies were investing heavily in Al, but Indian IT service companies focused on short- term gains and not R&D. And look at today: Japan Times is saying India lost a big AI opportunity, and that's true. We're the world's biggest Al consumers and nowhere in AI innovation. Sad?

Indian governments across the country are taking millions of dollars in debt to fund short-term freebies and direct cash transfers to people just to get votes. This short-sightedness is costing us now and will cost us in the future, bro. The WILL is ZERO not just in the government but private players are also happy with zero R&D and dollars flowing from the US in exchange for services, not innovation. We're happy with

American AI APIs :)

reddit.com
u/Raj_walker — 20 hours ago

I guess people now in India are becoming completely idiots. My blood boils whenever I see videos like these. Because of 1billion retards these politicians thinks they owns the country.

u/thehiddenmomo — 1 day ago

'Naked, Engulfed In Flames': Delhi Man Burned To Death By Wife, Mother-in-Law, Probe Underway

Delhi: A man was allegedly burned alive and killed by his wife and mother-in-law in the Jahangirpuri police station area of the North West district. The police have taken the mother-daughter duo into custody and have commenced their interrogation. Investigation is underway.

The owner of the house, where the incident happened, says, "Last night at 8:30 PM, when news of a fire broke out, my husband, my mother-in-law, and I were inside the house; we initially assumed the fire had started somewhere outside or that a short circuit had occurred. Subsequently, people gathered at our doorstep and informed us that the fire was actually inside our own home. As soon as we stepped outside to investigate, we saw a young man descending from above while engulfed in flames. He then fell down the staircase, landed at the bottom, and lay there; he was completely naked, and his entire body was severely burnt. After lying there for about 10 minutes, he gave a statement. We called the SHO because, at that moment, we were unable to get through to the emergency helpline (112)... We also called for an ambulance... An officer arrived from the police station and recorded the young man's statement on his phone; in it, the victim alleged that his wife and mother-in-law had set him on fire, and that they had also enlisted the help of 2-3 other individuals. He also made certain allegations regarding an affair—claiming that his wife was involved with 2-3 other men... When we informed his family about the incident, his wife refused to come downstairs, stating that he should simply be left to burn... No one from his family came forward. The police arrived later; they took his statement and transported him away in the ambulance. Later, we learned that he had passed away..."

Source - News Article

u/theanonymoussking — 21 hours ago

What happens if India becomes #1 on the global Press Freedom Index?

Many of us romanticize the idea of India becoming #1 on the global Press Freedom Index, including me when it fits my agenda, as if unrestricted information automatically creates a healthier democracy. A democrazy of 1.5 billion where the value of vote is 1-2k on the election date.

IMO a fully liberal media ecosystem only works in societies with strong civic discipline, critical thinking, and institutional trust. India already struggles with deep polarization, emotional politics, celebrity worship, and low media literacy or in general literacy at scale. How many of us have looked beyond our academics or scoring marks in the exams ? Hell some don’t even care for mid terms and only the finals.

This is a country where people divide themselves into almost all sorts of digital tribes over everything imaginable. Fans of Varun Dhawan fighting fans of Christopher Nolan both sides having a go at it. Fans of Virat Kohli willing to abuse or threaten entire families because someone said he should retire. Now imagine this same emotional ecosystem amplified by completely unrestricted political, communal, ideological, and AI-generated narratives competing 24/7 for attention. People are throwing animals into canals to record videos of them saving and for social media points. Willing to assassinate anyone’s career for some insta views.

In a low-trust society with existing religious, caste, regional, linguistic, and political fractures, absolute narrative freedom can easily become informational warfare. I mean take bihar for example where a guy with some records is their CM, we elected these leaders. In many states we voted the ones who are offering freebies despite we being a deficit in almost all areas, what will happen with #1 press freedom ?

A democracy survives not just because people are free to speak, but because society is capable of processing information responsibly. Absolute chaos can become democrazy. For the propaganda machines, our job is to completely boycott and reject these media houses, let their rallies dry. But what are we doing ?

Maybe it’s time to retrospect within ourselves. A poor press freedom also means, a poor critical thinking society.

reddit.com
u/IREDA1000 — 19 hours ago
▲ 366 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+3 crossposts

What If Afforestation Beat Deforestation in India?

What If Afforestation Really Outpaced Deforestation in India?

India’s official forest and tree cover data suggests that green cover has increased, which sounds like excellent news at first glance. But many environmentalists argue that this does not automatically mean our natural forests are recovering. A plantation of eucalyptus, bamboo, or other commercial species is not the same as an old natural forest with rich biodiversity, stable soil, water retention, and wildlife habitat.

That creates an important question: should we judge forest policy mainly by total tree cover, or by the ecological quality of the land being restored? If afforestation is growing faster than deforestation on paper, but natural forests are still being fragmented or replaced, can we really call that a success?

Question arises :-

Are we actually restoring forests, or just increasing the number of trees on paper?

What should matter more in forest policy: total tree cover, or the quality of the ecosystem?

Sources 👇🏼

1.(India State of Forest report)

https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2086742&reg=3&lang=2

2.(India percentage in forest cover)

https://www.pib.gov.in/FactsheetDetails.aspx?Id=150425&reg=3&lang=2

3.(Experts against Forest survey)

https://www.indiatoday.in/magazine/up-front/story/20250303-forest-survey-fading-green-of-india-2683457-2025-02-21

4.(Eucalyptus in india)

https://www.fao.org/4/xii/0500-b2.htm

5.(Eucalyptus as a waterlogging control)

https://naas.org.in/Policy%20Papers/Policy%2074.pdf

6.(Eucalyptus inventory in india)

https://epubs.icar.org.in/index.php/IJA/article/view/173142/63371

u/Formula_explains — 1 day ago
🔥 Hot ▲ 8.8k r/CriticalThinkingIndia+1 crossposts

A decades-old story from Pune’s iconic Jangli Maharaj Road has resurfaced online after many locals recalled how a stretch of road built several decades ago reportedly lasted nearly 50 years without developing major potholes.

A decades-old story from Pune’s iconic Jangli Maharaj Road has resurfaced online after many locals recalled how a stretch of road built several decades ago reportedly lasted nearly 50 years without developing major potholes or structural damage becoming a symbol of rare long-term infrastructure quality in India.

The road, often cited in urban infrastructure discussions, became famous for its exceptional durability despite heavy traffic and changing weather conditions over the years.

While parts of the story around the contractors being “blacklisted” remain more anecdotal than officially documented, the incident is frequently referenced as a commentary on how modern infrastructure projects are often criticized for poor durability, repeated repairs, and maintenance-driven contracting systems.

The conversation has reignited larger public frustration around road quality, civic accountability, and whether India’s infrastructure ecosystem prioritizes long-term engineering quality or short-term repair cycles.

Maintenance of Roads and Highways

  • The Ministry received an allocation of about ₹3.1 lakh crore for 2026–27, with a major share going to the development and maintenance of national highways through the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI).
  • Around ₹1.87 lakh crore has been allocated to NHAI, which is responsible for highway development and maintenance. This is about a 10% increase over the previous revised estimate.
  • The report highlights continued focus on:
    • highway upgradation,
    • widening of roads,
    • expressway construction,
    • and improving connectivity under programmes like Bharatmala Pariyojana.
  • Concerns remain regarding:
    • rising maintenance burden due to expansion of highway networks,
    • dependence on borrowings and monetisation,
    • and slower road construction pace in 2025–26.
  • The analysis also indicates that maintenance and asset quality are becoming increasingly important as India’s highway network expands rapidly.

Road Accidents and Road Safety

  • Allocation for Road Transport and Safety in 2026–27 is only ₹400 crore, despite India having one of the world’s highest numbers of road accident fatalities.
  • PRS notes that utilisation of road safety funds averaged only about 63% between 2017–26, indicating implementation gaps.
  • The report links road safety challenges to:
    • poor enforcement,
    • unsafe road design,
    • increasing traffic volume,
    • and inadequate safety infrastructure.
  • External analyses cited alongside the budget discussion argue that spending on road safety is very small compared to toll revenue and highway expansion spending.
  • The broader policy emphasis continues to be on:
    • reducing accident fatalities,
    • black spot correction,
    • better engineering standards,
    • and safer highway corridors.

We should develop better roads in India that lasts longer to Grow Our Economy and the accidents due to Potholes.

Sources: https://prsindia.org/budgets/parliament/demand-for-grants-2026-27-analysis-road-transport-and-highways

https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/jangli-maharaj-road-pune-history-hot-mix-technology-pothole-free-indian-streets-pothole-plague-pmc-civil-engineering-2770138-2025-08-14

u/SuperbHealth5023 — 2 days ago

What are your thoughts on sibi george answer to the journalist question.

A journalist asked why should we trust you , will you stop the human right violations in india , will pm start taking questions from Indian media in future .

And sibi answered about the past achivements like invention of zero, chess. He was telling about how old our ancient civilization is. About the g20 summit hosting and uniting the world. Covid supplies, pm greatness of hosting g20 and Ai summit. Largest democracy. He emphasised that India guarantees fundamental rights, equality, freedom of expression and legal protections under its constitution. Going to court.

But he didn't answer the question about the human right violations and pm answering to the press. Why are we so struck to past achievements and hosting summits. We know how long and painful our court process is and we aren't addressing.

People are praising him for the answer and saying it's agenda

https://www.financialexpress.com/india-news/let-me-finish-no-understanding-of-india-mea-secretary-sibi-george-lashes-out-at-norwegian-journalist-watch/4244494/lite/

https://youtu.be/cRiPt398sXY

u/Snehith220 — 1 day ago

Can india ever fully modernize?

Hear me out india couldn't have its own enlightenment age due to some reasons can anyone explain on that bit was it lack of a severe depoplutaton event or was it colonialism

It kinda saddenes me that how far behind the country is lagging be it strict endogamy and feudalism in majority of country or corruption

I am basically asking what went wrong in case of India which failed to modernize or westernize arrange marriage still dominates honor killings still take place at large even in cities joint family still is norm so is protien defecency and fanaticsm will indian society ever modernize? Not to mention the failure of education system

Also even if it modernize it will at what cost will there be a full blown civil war which will lead to like more than half of population gone which would be disturbing as in nuclear age and our neighbours like China and pak or it will stay status quo till the end of world

Also this post is kinda a rant/vent

reddit.com
u/Massive_Service_2318 — 20 hours ago

This is Deepika Nagar. She got married 14 months ago, and died last night.

This is Deepika Nagar. She got married 14 months ago, and died last night.

Deepika's in-laws called the police and said that Deepika had jumped from the roof and committed suicide.

Deepika's family says—they had given a Mahindra Scorpio-N, 5.71 lakh rupees in cash, 16 gold rings, and gold jewelry for the mother-in-law at the wedding.

Even after giving all this, Deepika's in-laws were demanding a Fortuner and 50 lakh rupees. They were harassing Deepika over this.

Regarding this matter, Deepika's father went to her in-laws' house yesterday to meet Deepika. There, he counseled her and pleaded with the in-laws not to trouble her.

After that, when they reached their home, they received a call saying your daughter has fallen, please come to the hospital.

When they arrived at the hospital, they found Deepika's body; the in-laws were not there.

📍Noida, UP

It's the high time that we actually go away with Dowry system and let the generation live peacefully. Those who pressurise to the girl's side should be sent to prison with strict laws.

Sources:

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/deepika-nagar-dowry-death-in-greater-noida-woman-falls-from-3rd-floor-year-after-wedding-11510621

https://www.timesnownews.com/city/noida/greater-noida-dowry-suicide-spleen-damaged-blood-clots-in-brain-shocking-details-emerge-in-deepika-death-case-article-154344329

u/SuperbHealth5023 — 1 day ago
▲ 586 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+1 crossposts

Don't go speed and have distance where you can break. Cow came infront the front car slowed, the other rammed into the truck trying to avoid.

: Four people were killed instantly in a tragic road accident on the Rishikesh–Haridwar highway late on Tuesday night after a speeding SUV rammed into a stationary truck.

The incident took place near the Mansa Devi railway crossing in Haridwar. According to police, a Mahindra XUV500 travelling at high speed from Haridwar towards Rishikesh crashed into the rear of a parked truck with such force that the SUV was completely crushed and became wedged underneath the larger vehicle.

Eyewitnesses told the police that the impact reduced the car to a mangled wreck. Preliminary investigations and witness accounts suggest that the SUV had been aggressively overtaking several vehicles moments before the collision.

The driver suddenly swerved sharply to the left, apparently to avoid an animal on the road. He lost control, and the car went straight into the back of the truck.

u/PentesterTechno — 2 days ago
▲ 642 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+2 crossposts

From Rumour to Stone Pelting: The Cost of Vigilante Justice!

Tension erupted in Hyderabad’s Gudimalkapur area after rumours about alleged cattle transportation triggered a confrontation between two groups, eventually leading to stone pelting and heavy police deployment.

According to reports, a group of self-styled cow vigilantes intercepted a container truck around midnight, suspecting it was carrying cattle illegally. However, police later clarified that the vehicle was transporting cardboard and plywood materials, not animals.

The incident once again highlights how rumours, moral policing, and vigilante behaviour can rapidly disturb public order and create fear among ordinary citizens. In recent years, several such episodes across India have shown how suspicion alone can escalate into harassment, violence, and communal tension before facts are even verified.

If self-appointed vigilante groups continue to create unrest based on rumours, then a serious question must be asked: who should ultimately take accountability for the atrocities and nuisance they create?

u/DioTheSuperiorWaifu — 2 days ago