r/AskAstrophotography

Rainbow halo artifact on bright stars with Newton and ASI533MC

Hi everyone,

I’m trying to understand a strange artifact on my setup and wondered if some of you already experienced this.

Setup:

  • SkyWatcher 150/750 (with Backyard Universe spider and full black flocking inside)
  • SkyWatcher coma corrector
  • ZWO ASI533MC Pro
  • No filter

On bright stars, I get a weird rainbow/green halo or ghost reflection.
What’s strange is that the artifact depends on the star position on the sensor: when the star moves across the field, the halo changes position too.

It even appears on very short exposures (~3s), so it does not seem related to long exposure blooming.

I’m wondering if this could come from:

  • internal reflections between the sensor window and coma corrector,
  • absence of UV/IR cut,
  • the coma corrector itself,
  • slight dew,

Has anyone seen something similar with a Newton + ASI533MC setup?

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Original-Task9398 — 4 hours ago
▲ 52 r/AskAstrophotography+1 crossposts

Rho Ophiucci, Dark River nebula and Milky Way

My setup:

  • Camera: M100 with stock lens
  • Focal length: 15mm
  • Aperture: f/3.5
  • Shutter Speed: 15 seconds
  • ISO: 3200
  • Took 80 RAW images
  • No star tracker
  • Stacked and edited in Siril

--------------------------

After a failure to capture the Sombrero Galaxy, this time I went to a relatively dark location and managed a better shot.

The idea was to blend two sets of photos (one for the foreground and a stacked one of the sky) so that the sea and Rho Ophiucci cloud complex are both visible. I messed up the foreground part so I just cropped a part of picture.

I'm still learning (this is only my 3rd attempt) so please provide constructive feedback.

  1. Is this a good photo or bad one?
  2. For landscape astrophotography, do you use a single shot of the foreground at higher exposure time than the photos of the sky?
  3. The stars at the edges of my photo were stretched (in the uncropped original image it was much worse than what you can see here). Why? I used a tripod of course but it was a bit windy. Should I hang a weighted bag on the tripod's hook? And should the bag touch the ground, or should it hang in the air?
  4. Even though I tooke 80 photos of 15s each, I could not make the photo bright enough without also making the dark parts bright. Any tips?
  5. Any tutorials or books for beginners?

Thanks for your time.

u/minas1 — 15 hours ago

Need help deciding on a camera to get into astrophotography

Hi, I have been wanting to get into astrophotography, and I have been doing a lot of research on cameras and how well they capture the night sky. I've been looking at these 5 cameras: Canon M50, Sony A6000, Nikon D750, Canon 5D Mark IV, and Sony A6400. I'm leaning towards the Nikon D750 because I like the photos it can take, and I can get it used for a good price. The Canon 5D Mark IV and Sony A6400 are a bit too out of my budget. What do you think about the cameras I’m considering, especially for astrophotography? Are there any major pros/cons I should know about, or any other cameras you’d recommend instead? Thank you.

reddit.com
u/No_Essay_5492 — 10 hours ago

goodbye walking noise, hello banding?

added a guidescope and dithered every 5th frame. exposures were kept to 30" to match exposures from prior nights which were tracked, but not guided/dithered. stacked in sirilic and edited in siril, now I have horizontal wide bands. suggestions appreciated

reddit.com
u/bioteacher01077 — 16 hours ago

What focal length do you find most versatile for nebulae on full frame?

Hey everyone,

I currently have a Star Adventurer with a Canon EOS 6D Mk II and a 50mm lens. I’ve used this setup quite a lot and now I’m looking to upgrade, mainly to get more focal length. I’m planning to move to a small apochromatic refractor.

I’m aware that the mount is key here. I first considered the Sky-Watcher EQ-AL55i, but I’m leaning toward going straight for the HEQ5 so I won’t need to upgrade the mount again later if I go for a bigger scope.

My main question is about focal length. I’d like something that frames most nebulae well, since galaxies, planetary nebulae, and globular clusters tend to be too small for this kind of setup anyway.

Right now I’m hesitating between:
- Askar SQA55 (264mm)
- Askar 60F (408mm)
- Askar 71F (490mm)

Since I’m shooting full-frame, I’m a bit worried the SQA55 might be too wide. On the other hand, one advantage is that I could still use it on the Star Adventurer (not ideal, I know, but workable), which would let me start using it sooner and save up for the HEQ5 afterward.

I’ve checked a lot of targets on Telescopius, and my impression is:
- some nebulae feel a bit small at 264mm,
- some feel a bit tight at 408mm,
- 490mm looks great for smaller nebulae, but large targets like M31 don’t fit well anymore.

I’d really appreciate feedback from anyone who has used similar setups or these scopes.

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/seb_skills — 15 hours ago

Beginner astrophotography setup?

Hi

Someone near me is selling an astro setup, and I’m a beginner trying to get into the hobby.

For reference I currently just have a Sony a6700 camera and an 18-50mm lense. I’ve only done milky way photos before.

The main parts of the setup are:
Skywatcher star adventurer 2i pro mount + tripod
William optics z61 telescope
ZWO asi183mc pro camera
ZWO asi120mm guide camera
ZWO Asiair pro
Sybony Guide scope

Also comes with a bunch of accessories, all the cables, and a case.

$2000 for everything

Does this seem like a good deal for a beginner setup? Mostly I’m looking to do dso photos and figure I can also use my Sony on the star tracker for general Milky Way photos.

Any thoughts? And if anyone has other recommendations for a beginner setup I’d appreciate it.

reddit.com
u/NumerousGene175 — 16 hours ago

Brand new rig, worrying about my flats

Hello everyone,

I just got my first serious astrophotography rig delivered (coming from an S30 Pro) and first thing I did was take flats to see if the gear is okay.

What concerns me are the splotches on the preview window in the ASIAir app. They look like there is something horribly wrong: https://i.imgur.com/GHZA7oV.jpeg

But then when I look at the flats in Siril/PixInsight, I can't see them. They seem almost too perfect?

Here is a Google Drive with a few of the flats as FITs: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1fCq783KUXvjKIwexxDHlkYxdYKrdM52B?usp=share_link

I used an iPad with a white sheet of paper. Tried with a tshirt, got the same result.

The relevant specs:

  • Askar 80PHQ
  • ASI2600MC Air
  • No filters for these flats

Really appreciate any advice.

u/Othir0xX — 21 hours ago

I want to start astrophotography but i am lost in the camera choices.

Hey everyone! I've been fascinated by astronomy and astrophotography for as long as I can remember, always stopping to stare at other people's shots of the night sky. I recently started university, and astronomy is quickly becoming a real hobby. Whenever the clouds cooperate, I'm out there stargazing and shooting long exposures with my phone.

Now I want to take the next step into actual astrophotography. At a university astronomy event I got talking to a local amateur astrophotography club, and they told me the basics for a low-budget setup are a decent reflex camera, good lenses, and a tripod. So I started hunting for a low-to-mid budget reflex camera and promptly got completely lost in specs.

I've searched online and asked AI tools, and while the Nikon D5600 keeps coming up as a solid beginner option, I still don't really understand what makes a camera good for astrophotography and I don't want to drop money on something that turns out to be a poor fit.

I also enjoy regular photography, so ideally I'd want a camera that handles both well. I just don't know which specs to prioritize for each use case.

EDIT : I am in Europe, Belgium

Any help from people who've been down this road would be massively appreciated thanks in advance!

reddit.com
u/HavocxKa — 22 hours ago

Planetary pictures

I've been viewing the moon and Jupiter through my newly acquired AD8 and have been using a celestron nexyz super fun and easy for the moon. But Jupiter is ridiculously hard to capture. Anyway I got the bug and want to invest a little into a dedicated planetary rig , to take pictures of all the planets. I see used celestron se 4 and 5 and 6 pretty frequently for sale used. But that has me wondering why lol. I don't want to stop using my DOB because It's amazing but I companion scope for pictures would be nice. 1k max budget. Something idiot proof and easy to learn.

reddit.com
u/sethsomething — 17 hours ago

Rate My First Serious Astrophotography Rig

Thinking of buying this astrophotography setup budget around 3 lakh rupees (3000 dollars)

• SVBONY SV545 Astrograph
• ZWO AM3 Mount
• ASI585MC Air
• Optolong L-eXtreme
• SVBONY Power Box
• TC40 Tripod

Mostly planning to shoot nebulae and galaxies. Any suggestions in the setup?

reddit.com
u/Average_Asian_Man1 — 22 hours ago

Using Meade Deep Sky Imager on Linux

I picked up an old Deep Sky Imager CCD from a flea market. I'm trying to get it working on my system but I'm getting confused with the different driver configurations.

Is there any guide to getting this to work on a modern Linux system?

reddit.com
u/WaitForItTheMongols — 24 hours ago

Just How Good is the Sky-Watcher EQ-AL55i Pro Guiding?

Looking at the AL55i to replace an ancient iOptron SmartEQ Pro. (Got fed up trying to get theis thing to work with NINA and I have low expections that it will guide well, too.)

Haven't found many good reviews online and none seem to address its guiding numbers.

So if you do astrophotography with the AL55i, what is your opnion and what kind of guiding numbers can I expect. looking for 1.0" IN GENERAL.

I will be using an Askar 71f and an ASI585MC Pro. Guide wset up is a 120mm focal length scope and an ASI224mm mini (I think, its in storage right now.)

reddit.com
u/gt40mkii — 19 hours ago

Looking for advice on a rig I am planning to get.

Hi Guys

I'll keep it short. I have gotten into astro over the last year or so and having originally got a DOB (Skyliner 200P), I realised pretty quickly that it was DSO that I enjoyed, particularly the image processing portion. I picked up an s50 last year and have enjoyed it, but I have since realised that it's had a fault this entire time that I am currently speaking with ZWO on (tracking is a mess, failed subs over 20s and star tracking/blurry photos every 3/4 subs on 10s).

So I have built out a sort of 'dream rig' based on the many recommendations I have seen here and honestly, I am just looking for someone to either confirm it's a good setup to aim towards, or if it's too excessive a jump from the Seestar. This is what I have put together:

  • Scope: Askar FRA400 Astro graph - €1325
  • Tripod: ZWO TC40 carbon Fibre Tripod - €385
  • Mount: ZWO AM5N Harmonic Equatorial Mount • €2212
  • Main camera: ZWO ASI2600MC Duo • €1927
  • Controller: ZWO ASIAIR Plus 256GB • €332
  • Autofocus: ZWO EAF Standard (5V) • €239
  • Power supply: PegasusAstro Power Supply 12V/10A Europe 2.1mm • €79
  • Dew heater: NEEWER USB Dew Heater Strip • €30
  • Dual-band filter: Optolong L-eXtreme • €323

Any advice would be appreciated. The goal is to focus on Nebula and Galaxies.

reddit.com
u/BlubberyGiraffe — 2 days ago

Dew heaters / lense warmers

I'm looking for a low powered lense warmer that will maintain a minimal internal temperature as efficiently as possible.

I am not an astrophotographer, I just suspect this community will be able to help me.

I will be taking this warmer up 4,000m peaks in the Alps. It will be fitted to a plastic lens instead of metal (thermal insulator, good and bad).

Esencailly,.I just need a warmer that will maintain the lens's internal temperature above the ambient temperature, bear In mind it will be close to my body the entire time. I'm thinking about maintaining 20-30°C would be about right, but I'm unsure. And I'm looking to find something very efficient so I don't need to carry a giant power bank, that will run out.

I also have the strange caveat that it has to be easily removed and attached (as easy as it gets), able to be done 1 handed (with some practice).

reddit.com
u/Piggy-boi — 1 day ago

How much more stops of light does H-alpha modified cameras let in?

I have a H-alpha modified Canon R, but I was wondering how many more stops of light a modification lets in. Has there been any data collection on this? I reckon below 1 stop of light, but that's just a guess.

reddit.com
u/TheFakeKevKev — 1 day ago

First-year astronomy student looking for raw deep-sky data/images for a final project! (M31, M42, M51, etc.)

Hello my fellow astropeeps!

I am a first-year astronomy student, and I am looking for some help with my final project for my Observational Astronomy major.

For the assignment, we need to collect 9 raw deep-sky images (3 clusters, 3 nebulae, and 3 galaxies) and write a narrative about their notable features. We are allowed to use data from the MicroObservatory, take the images ourselves, or ask the astrophotography community for help! (We are strictly prohibited from using Hubble, JWST, or any other space telescopes).

For the images used, we must credit the source with the following details:

- Equipment used (Telescope, mount, camera, filters)

- Full name of the astrophotographer

- Imaging date and time

- Full name of the processor (if applicable)

- Software used

I am planning to work with the following targets, and I would be incredibly grateful if anyone would be willing to share their raw data/sub-frames and these acquisition details with me:

Galaxies:

- Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

- Whirlpool Galaxy (M51)

- Sombrero Galaxy (M104)

Clusters:

- Pleiades (M45)

- Hercules Globular Cluster (M13)

- [Already have one]

Nebulae:

- Orion Nebula (M42)

- Lagoon Nebula (M8)

- Ring Nebula (M57)

If you have data for any of these targets and don't mind sharing, please let me know! Thank you so much in advance for helping a future astronomer out. Clear skies!

reddit.com
u/hycnthmthyst — 2 days ago

Filters for Color Camera

I'm putting together a rig based around an SVBONY SV605MC and was wondering if it would be better to go with just a 3nm HaO3 filter or a 7nm HaO3 plus a 7nm S2O3 filter. Cost is a bit of a concern so I'm trying to stick with these cheaper SVBONY filters.

reddit.com
u/Russian_Bot1337 — 1 day ago

Is my collimation good?

I messed with my screws on my Celestron 6SE and I want to collimate to ensure good focus. I did a quick defocused star check and it looks pretty decent, but I’m skeptical because of the fact I messed with the screws. Am I missing something? Any help is appreciated, and if you need extra information don’t hesitate to ask.

(Can’t upload images so I have the images in a Google Drive folder)

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/10w-JBbxSrNBWc8PK4536JLiuAGR9wMnt

reddit.com
u/uttersimba — 1 day ago

Astro Coverage Planner | See where you've imaged. Plan what's next. Send it to N.I.N.A.

Hey all,

I've been building a tool for myself over the past few months and it's finally polished enough to share. Posting here in case anyone else would find it useful.

Repo: https://github.com/astro-roro/Astro-Coverage-Planner (MIT licensed)

Why Build ACP?

After 70-odd targets across a number of different rigs I'd lost track of what was actually finished vs what was sitting at "Hα done, SII still needed". Spreadsheets weren't cutting it. I wanted ONE map of the sky showing every field I'd ever imaged, coloured by rig, with per-filter hours on each target and a whole bunch more. So I built it all out and this is the v1.0 I am happy enough to share publicly.

What ACP Does:

  • Scans your FITS/XISF archive (about 5 minutes for 100k files), reads WCS + gear headers, clusters into targets, plots every field on an Aladin Lite sky map.
  • Creates FOV polygons coloured by telescope, badged by filter. Click any one to see per-filter hours and the masters behind it.
  • Toggleable sky-survey backgrounds — flip between optical, Hα, infrared, radio with one click. Your coverage stays locked in place while the sky changes character. This is personally my favourite bit.
  • Catalogue overlays: Green 2019 SNR, SMGPS / EMU SNR candidates, WISE HII, Messier, Sharpless, ESO PNe (more to come).
  • Cross-source gap-finder. Pick "have Hα" + "missing SII", set hour thresholds, and it lights up every region of sky where one filter is covered but the other isn't, with public-catalogue candidates scattered in the gap.
  • 12-month visibility per target for your site (sparklines on every object, "Now: Good · ↑ Improving" trend chips, sort by up-tonight).
  • Mosaic-aware planner that exports directly to NINA Target Scheduler (projects, exposure templates, per-panel targets, all tested cleanly against TS 5).
  • Plugin platform if you want to add custom catalogues, coverage sources, or other planners (Voyager / SGP would be great PRs).

AI Disclosure

Up front: AI did a lot of the implementation, but I am a real SWE that cares about good code practices. This is a hobby tool for me, and I didn’t want to spend years creating it from scratch. HOWEVER; what I cared about and spent real time on: input validation and security defaults (binds to localhost, no auth on a dev server, clear warnings if you change either), performance (MOC algebra for the gap-finder, cached visibility per site), and end-to-end testing (the NINA TS export went through five schema iterations against a real install before I trusted it). Not a vibe-coded toy. Happy to walk through any of the architecture in replies if you have concerns.

What’s next?

I will be continuing to work on this to bring more features into it, but always keen to hear if this is useful to others and what they would like. I find it very satisfying being able to see where I have imaged and where I am yet to capture data on.

Cheers,
Rohan - Astro With RoRo

u/BlakPhoenix — 2 days ago