Obsession Theory: The Film’s TRUE villain
A lot of discussion has been taking place over the last few days regarding who the villain of Obsession truly is. Is it Bear? (Yes) Is it Freaky Nikki? (Also yes). Is it the real Nikki? (No and it’s fucking weird that people actually try to argue that). However I believe we are foolishly focusing on the wrong characters solely because they take up the majority of screen time. I believe the film’s ultimate villain, the true master mind behind everything is…Sandy!
Look, we all know Cats are evil: Katz from Courage the Cowardly Dog, the Cat demons from All Dogs go to Heaven, the fact that the movie Cats (2019) was ever made in the first place, etc. So I believe Sandy purposefully orchestrated the events of the entire movie using her own suicide to set things into motion. And we get our evidence for this very early on.
Right after Bear makes his wish “freaky” Nikki mentions that HER cat just died before quickly correcting to Bear’s cat having just died. Many mistakenly believe that this is whatever is possessing Nikki trying to mimic the real Nikki and not getting it quite right. But I saw this “slip up” for what it truly was. Undeniable, irrefutable proof that Sandy was living a double life as BOTH Bear AND Nikki’s pet cat, sneaking out at random intervals to occupy both spaces at different times.
“But, but TJ” I hear you say “Sandy was dead the whole time! How could she be the villain.” You silly goober, Sandy PLANNED TO DIE FROM THE BEGINNING. She truly exemplifies hater energy. Giving her own life to take out both of her owners. She would have known that Bear has feelings for Nikki, and she would have known that Nikki wants Bear at trivia night so they can win. So she deliberately became bipedal, used her paws to carefully open the child safety cap on the medication, and staged her own death scene.
She knew that this would make Bear apprehensive about going to trivia so Nikki would have to call him to convince him. She would have also known that Nikki is clumsy and can’t multitask well, thus Bear would hear her drop her necklace down the drain and wind up at that store to purchase the one wish willow and make his wish, setting their inevitable downfall into motion.
“But TJ,” I hear you ask again “how would Sandy have known about the one wish willows?” Well, if you accept the above to be true, which I have just laid out all the ways it objectively is, then the only logical conclusion is that SANDY WAS ACTUALLY LIVING A TRIPLE LIFE AS THE STORE CLERK’S SECRET PET AS WELL.
Therefore Sandy knew Bear would pathetically not be able to ask out Nikki. She knew he’d be drawn to the one wish willow and the wish would go awry quickly. She knew that Nikki would get possessed and that they would both eventually be destroyed by the wish. And why did she do all this? Fuck if I know, Bear probably forgot to feed her once or something. Cats are evil man.
TL;DR: Sandy is an evil mastermind.