Lively phone vs a dedicated medical alert for actual emergency coverage
The Lively phone as a combined solution makes intuitive sense until you look at what the emergency coverage actually requires to work. Calling for help requires the phone to be present, charged, and consciously activated by someone who may not be able to do any of those things. Passive fall detection is not part of the equation at all.
The all in one appeal is real for simplicity.
But the emergency performance is a pretty different category from a dedicated worn device.