Well, I have a very close relationship with someone (my mother) who is probably an ESTJ. The thing is, I'm almost certain that Si is my PoLR (I already know why I'm an ENTJ/ENFJ).
The truth is, my hypothesis for why we clash is that we don't just have problems with Ni/Si, but also with Fi. I think this person has a Si-Fi combination that is hard for me to understand because I don't value it; it genuinely feels like a "whim" to me, although I know it’s not that way for her. I’d like some advice on how to detect when Si (the sensory environment) is more important than my Ni (the long-term purpose) for her. Sometimes I find her priorities excessively irritating, and I want to learn to be more mindful of them before they escalate, as this is a long-standing problem. Here is an example of a situation that made me think, "I can't take it anymore."
We work together and usually don't have issues, except when we both try to impose our will. For context, someone who collects plastic bottles often passes by our workplace. Since I care about environmentalism, I started saving my clean bottles to give them directly to this person. To me, it was the perfect plan, so I stored them near the cleaning supplies. She saw them and was immediately annoyed because, to her, they were "trash" and could attract insects. I told her it was fine because they were clean and just plastic, but she took my explanation as if I were calling her an exaggerator. She got upset and insisted she "didn't want to see them" simply because she said so. To me, this felt like a total whim—the bottles weren't in her way. When I asked if she could just wait until the collector came, she told me to just throw them in the trash outside and let the person find them there.
For me this was illogical: why separate them only to mix them back with trash?.Eventually, I moved the bag out of her "workspace," but the argument escalated because of that Si-Fi trigger. She couldn't give me a "logical" reason; she just kept saying, "Because I want it that way!"
At the time, I dismissed it as drama over a whim. I realized later that I was invalidating her because her argument lacked the kind of "purpose" I value. I hadn't considered that maintaining her immediate sensory environment was so vital to her peace of mind, or that "waiting" for my plan to finish would cause her so much stress. I’d appreciate any advice on how to spot these Si-needs sooner.
(One more thing: I don't think she had anything against giving the person the bottles; it was just that our ways of resolving the situation clashed.)