Very tough decision deciding between two schools
Hello everyone,
This cycle I was extremely fortunate enough to have been accepted into a PA program. Today I just received a phone call that I got out of the waitlist for another program. However, I am very conflicted choosing between the two programs. Hopefully you guys can guide me.
Program A originally accepted me all the way back in September. Program B is the one that called me today. Both are in California. Both start this August.
| Program A | Program B | |
|---|---|---|
| Accreditation | Accredited | Provisional |
| Cost | $156,915 | $143,582 |
| PANCE pass rate | 2021 96% 2022 91% 2023 89% 2024 82% 2025 85% | 2023 93% 2024 97% |
| Attrition rate | 2022-2025 0% | 2023 3.5% 2024 0% 2025 3% |
| Location | Bay Area; 9 hours from where I currently live in SoCal | SoCal; where I currently live and 2hr drive from my family |
| Clinical locations | IIRC; they are literally scattered throughout the state. Not ideal. | Within two counties, all within a 2-hour drive (at max) |
| Program length | 28 months | 28 months |
Objectively, program B is the better option. What concerns me about program A is the drop in the PANCE pass rate however last year they seemed to have reversed the decline.
I would accept program B in a heartbeat. But now I present to you my dilemma. Last week I just submitted my application for the NHSC scholarship. With my very high GPA, letter of rec's and background I believe I have a good chance at earning the scholarship. Which, if you don't know, pays for everything. Which is especially important given the new loan changes. Now, for that scholarship I told them I was attending program A. If I commit to program B, i essentially forfeit that scholarship. But, given the new loan changes, I suspect there was a major uptick in applicants which may make it way more competitive. Which makes me think what if I commit to program A for the scholarship, but I don't end up getting it while I just forfeited my seat to a slightly cheaper program.
Program B just makes sense to me. I have lived in the area where the program is at for the past 5 years, have gotten to know the healthcare system and institutions very well, familiar with the population, and is 2 hour drive from my family. I may even land a job where i currently work at as an ED tech. The only con i can think of for program B is that its a religious based institution and Im not that personally religious.
Please leave your thoughts down below. They have only given me 3 days to make a decision lol.