u/_user_638

Is this a proof in defence of Abu Bakr RA?

The ayah in use:
Surah Tawbah: 40 (about the prophet ﷺ and abu bakr RA in the cave)
Surah Ash_Shu'ara: 61-62 (about Musa AS and bani israel)

The prophet ﷺ whilst in the cave says to abu bakr "Allah is with US". How can Allah support a person that will kill the prophets daughter and neglect his family's rights as according to the shia. We see in another verse with the companions of Musa AS, he mentions that "Allah is with ME", he does not say "Allah is with US". This is because the companions of Musa AS betrayed him, thus Allah is not with them. 
(26:61-62)

If the shia claim that: "Allah was only with the prophet ﷺ and abu bakr in that exact moment", then what of bani israel and Musa AS. They too were only with Musa AS in that moment however later betrayed him. Thats why Musa AS says that "Allah is with ME", he does not say "US". therefore the claim that Allah was only with them in that moment is false due to the example of Musa AS and bani israel

reddit.com
u/_user_638 — 4 hours ago