question about an interview question on behalf of my husband
My husband is trying for his third year in a row to get into the pipefitters union; the first 2 times, nerves got the best of him, and he failed the math test due to extreme anxiety despite aceing the practice test. This time, he practiced and worked on his test-taking anxiety and passed with flying colors so he is moving on to the interview! Not just that but he has a ton of points this year, has taken 3 welding and welding inspection classes, has his HVAC-R certification, and has been working in a manual labor management role for the past year. I really think this year is the year he has a great chance at getting in.
He got a little sheet with some example questions for the interview and we are practicing his answers together. One that is tripping us up is
"Imagine a scenario where your foreman or journeyman tells you, 'You're wrong, ' but you disagree, what would you do?"
His answer is that he is working under their license and trusts them that they have the most current, up-to-date information, and that ultimately, he is the trainee and they are the mentor, so he will follow their instructions.
I said maybe it's a trick question to see if you would have the "brass" to have a reasonable disagreement with your superior if they are asking you to do something out of regulation or that compromises safety, and now we both don't know what a good answer.
What would your answer be? Also, I am handy, but I am not in the trades, so I could very well be totally wrong on my interpretation of the question, you won't hurt my feelings if you say so lol.