u/Throwaway_Dad35

​

I honestly don’t even know where to start anymore.

A few months ago there was a family incident involving the discipline of one of my children. Police got involved. CPS got involved. I was arrested in front of my family and a criminal no-contact order was entered involving one child.

Then CPS created what they called a “safety plan” that effectively pushed me out of my own home and away from all of my children indefinitely.

I never signed it. I never had a hearing about it. But I followed it anyway because I thought cooperating would help my family heal and get back together faster.

So for nearly 3 months:

I stayed away from my kids,

stayed out of my house,

jumped through every hoop,

talked to counselors,

dealt with attorneys,

tried to stay calm,

apologized when I got emotional,

and kept asking one question:

“What do I need to do to go home?”

Instead of answers, everything became delays, vague explanations, and shifting narratives. CPS later blamed attorney communication issues, but the records show we were the ones constantly trying to get communication moving.

The worst part is that it felt like the more I asserted my rights or questioned things, the worse everything got.

Eventually the criminal no-contact issue was resolved legally through court. I went home and held my children for the first time in months. There was no new incident. No emergency. No violence. No new allegations. There was even a surprise visit from an officer and case worker one Friday night that went very positively and ended with no safety concerns.

The Monday after CPS removed the children.

What destroys me is the feeling that this stopped being about helping my family and became about protecting the system’s narrative. Every emotional reaction I had after months of separation got treated like proof against me, while the actual emotional damage to my wife and kids from keeping me away seemed ignored.

I’m not pretending I handled every moment perfectly. I’ve admitted where I could have done better. But I truly believed cooperating and respecting the process would matter. Instead it feels like once CPS decides what story they want to tell, everything gets bent to fit it.

I don’t know if I’m looking for advice, support, or just to hear from people who survived something similar.

​

I’m posting anonymously because this is still ongoing and I already have counsel. I’m looking more for procedural perspective and experiences from people familiar with CPS systems.

Earlier this year there was a family discipline incident involving one child. Police and CPS got involved. I was arrested and a criminal no-contact order was entered for that child only.

At the same time, CPS created a “safety plan” while I was not present. I never signed it, was never given a copy, and never had a court hearing about it. But CPS treated it as barring me from the home and from all of my children indefinitely.

Even though I disputed parts of it, I followed it anyway because I didn’t want things escalated further. I stayed out of the house for nearly 3 months.

Here’s where things get complicated:

CPS later claimed delays happened because our attorney required communication through lawyers only. But call records and meeting transcripts show we were repeatedly trying to get communication going despite CPS claiming they wouldn't meet or talk with us without their lawyer present.

CPS also claimed they made “reasonable efforts,” but there was very little forward movement for months. No clear reunification path, no visitation or even phone calls, inconsistent communication, no contact with the assigned safety monitor, not one check-in with the kids, and no additional investigation or assessments were made in those nearly 3 months.

The medical follow-up at a mobile clinic a few days later after the original incident was by a registered nurse and showed no injury requiring further workup, but CPS first discounted it as a "nurse visit" the later denied being provided the report at all.

Eventually the criminal no-contact issue was first modified then resolved through court. I returned home on a Friday and saw my children for the first time in months. I told CPS this during a phone call that day to set up a time to discuss a prevention case the next Friday. Later that night an officer and CPS worker made an unexpected but overall very positive visit where she had no safety concerns and recommended to keep working with the prevention team the next week.

The Monday after CPS/police removed the children through shelter care despite no new allegations, and a positive visit days earlier.

What I’m trying to understand from people who know this system:

How common is it for unsigned “voluntary” safety plans to function like de facto removal orders?

Is it normal for safety plans to go months without meaningful review/modification?

What documentation tends to matter most when disputing CPS timelines or communication claims?

How do courts typically view “reasonable efforts” arguments when there was little actual progress for weeks/months?

I’m trying very hard to stay factual and document-based because I know emotions can muddy these discussions.

I’m not saying CPS should never investigate. My concern is that the process became increasingly punitive after I asserted rights and involved attorneys.