u/Serious_Camera_7039 — reddlx

Very sensible and non sensational take on the recent incident in pindi.

Shame on u/Eastern_Degree_9763 for posting a cut off screenshot

He made it seem like I was calling Punjabis "spiritual offspring if fascists" but that is dumb as fuck because I am Punjabi!

I told him I was referring to one person who was just casually calling other people "backward" which is racist and ethnofacist behavior and it is haram.

He is a hateful little troll who is trying to spread hatred for no reason. He uses people's love for punjab to make them agree to hating others. You dont have hate someone else to love your own history and culture.

Xenophobic people are a blight everywhere in the world. Just talk to reform voters in the UK, BJP in India and MAGA in America, they're all losers who blame their inadequacies on others. We should not let Punjab be infested by hateful goblins because it will be the end of our province's beauty.

Its even more shameful that these people exist because Punjab has historically been the stronghold of democracy. We have always voted against the wishes of the establishment elite and we're the only province that has no regional party because we have had all 3 major parties rule here at least once.

Another breakup of Pakistan will be disastorous for Punjab like it will for the other provinces. I dont know if these racists are naive to it or they're towing some agenda for exactly that outcome but one thing is clear, there is no need of xenophobia in Pak Punjab, the only beneficiary of that is India.

u/Serious_Camera_7039 — 3 days ago

▲ 8 r/LeftPakistan

As far as I understand marxist theory, and feel free to correct me here, Capitalism is the stage preceding socialism that must take place. To elaborate, it means you cant just go straight from feudalism to socialism. I wont pretend, I know exactly why but a very compelling reason seems that it's difficult to develop class consciousness on a large scale without the exploitation of the capitalists.

In a feudal economy, the distinctions are more tribal, ethnic and religious so it's hard to unite people around the idea of shared purpose of the workers. So if that it the case would it not be a priority to accelerate the shift from a feudal economy to a capitalist economy first?

Like serfdom exists in a large part of the country, people are indebted to their landowners till they can work off their loans. If for an example you went straight to socialism and distributed the land out to the peasantry, would it not lead to an immediate reduction in food production at least for a while leading to potential famines? Of course it will take time to equip peasants with the same knowledge and equipment as their land owners and all that time, people still need to be fed.

A pretty glaring rebuttal of my argument is literally the fact that almost all socialist experiments occurred in feudal economies, not capitalist economies for e.g Russia and China. But I feel that's the 1 reason they had the few flaws they did. Socialism raised the standard of living for people in these countries massively but at the cost famines and the loss of some political and religious freedoms. Could that not be avoided through an intermediary capitalist stage where income equality was at least less worse than feudalism and political awareness among the lower classes is much great?

Lmk what u guys think.

reddit.com

u/Serious_Camera_7039 — 11 days ago

▲ 8 r/alevels

Not 1 account here is above 1-10 karma. Plus all the comments "dm me the le*k paper are also under 10 karma accounts". This is obviously trying to catch people for the scam and cause panic.

u/Serious_Camera_7039 — 11 days ago

▲ 1.5k r/leftist+1 crossposts

For transparency's sake, to anyone that cares, I'm not a US citizen just like the progressives cuz they dont want to actively fuck the rest of the world sideways like establishment republicans and democrats.

u/Cloud_Cultist — 12 days ago

▲ 52 r/pakistan

Didn't know pragmatism meant standing side by side with your literal arch nemesis. This is just an awful lineup of countries to be in.

u/Serious_Camera_7039 — 13 days ago