Perspectives on ANP in critical care
As someone senior and a specilist overseas in a rich western country, working as a clinical fellow here, I would like to share some thoughts.
- ANPs are definite taking on doctor roles here. They can prescribe, do invasive procedures and manage critical care patients indendpently.
- ANPs, in my experience, dont have the same dedication or committment to patients or self education. If there is an emergency, they all take their breaks and hardly come to help. I have never hear them quote an article and refer something academic or evdience based. Its invariably, ''this is what we do here'', as if that is more important than thougthfuly individualised care
- ANPs, - at handovers, I cant trust anything the say. Vast majority of is just repeition, with no sight, and full of factual errors. I really do wonder if they are actually helpful sometimes, because I have to repeat everything they do
- ANPs may work well in very niche areas where there is little risk of patient harm and where guidelines completely dominate.
- Dunning-kruger effect seems to be peaking in many of them.
- Finally, the worst is their complete lack of responsiblity. If doctors F up, then you may not progress, you many not get that training post, you may not get that consultant post, you will not be respected. For them, they seem to have the fun without the responsbility or the accountability. That is a perverse reward system.
I think they act as F1/F2 level at best, but without the humility, the dedication and motivation to become better. For them, it mostly seems like a job, not calling
My experience are are based in two hospitals, one in outer London and the other in Scotland, at foundation trusts , all rated very highly