u/Regular-Sell-8192

A NON-EXISTENT PAINTER (J. HANTER) IS ALWAYS OVERESTIMATED BY CATAWIKI EXPERTS ON X10. THE MYSTERY OF AN OLD FRIENDSHIP. M.R. ARROYO

A NON-EXISTENT PAINTER (J. HANTER) IS ALWAYS OVERESTIMATED BY CATAWIKI EXPERTS ON X10. THE MYSTERY OF AN OLD FRIENDSHIP. M.R. ARROYO

The artist J. Hanter, who doesn't actually exist (it's a name invented by the painter María Rosario Arroyo due to the many negative reviews she received), is always overvalued in expert estimates by a factor that multiplies the hammer price tenfold. https://www.catawiki.com/en/u/26576211-de-gea-art

https://preview.redd.it/ffx07h8fv90h1.jpg?width=1006&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=01acb2bc7019e0c6719db0f98d902134f155a9d4

https://preview.redd.it/9a5hei8fv90h1.jpg?width=1006&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ddd11bf255bc5f6c62b7341255a0ee222d288cdc

Take a look. There are more lots to see.

These auctions aren't over yet, that's true. But we'll be able to see the usual results, which I've already checked many times.

What the hell is that "Gallery Estimated" price??? Which gallery??? Are you kidding??? Catawiki experts: Do you think we're stupid?

Damn experts! Don't they have any shame? Or are they acting this way on purpose, following orders "from above"??

This "painter" continues to use the same trick she used before: a digital print covered in paint to pretend it's an original oil painting. It's true that she now uses more paint, though. But she paints the canvas from behind with a roller, creating curious, leopard-print patterns, in a sloppy attempt to hide the digital print if someone were to look through it under a strong light...

https://preview.redd.it/2g7rvbgtv90h1.png?width=585&format=png&auto=webp&s=4d91278a1bad0c28b49161d7f35f0620e279c0e1

What kind of shitty practice is this? Who, in the name of God, covers the canvas with roller paint from behind in such a suspicious way?

This artist also has a second shop on Catawiki where she offers sculptures, which are also overvalued by experts:

https://www.catawiki.com/en/u/5013993-mariarosario23

It is the story of an old "friendship" that began with the unconditional protection of the expert Tatiana Ruiz and that has become a tradition followed by Itziar Ramos, Anthony Chrisp, Egidio Emiliano, and many others who apparently have all studied at the same university and all them agree in the estimation of these paintings which -this is a purely personal opinion of mine- are a real piece of crap painted by a clumsy amateur who demonstrates that she has never known what good brushwork means. And the experts know even less.

Catawiki art experts, I recommend applying for a position at Sotheby's or Christie's; they'll welcome you with open arms, no doubt! (ask Tatiana Ruiz; she used to work at Christie's some years ago...)

reddit.com
u/Regular-Sell-8192 — 4 days ago

What's going on in the Art section?

When an artist sends their pieces from a specific country, the lots are always filtered by the same experts (for the logical reason of standardizing languages). They are then assigned to the appropriate auctions, but the filtering process is usually the same.

So, if you send art from Spain, the filtering expert is very often Carmen Iñiguez Berbeira, Itziar Ramos or others from the same team, and the supervisor is Heiko Neitzel.

What happens when someone sends a lot with a reserve price, it's accepted, but the lot doesn't sell? They don't let you resubmit it unless you don't set a reserve price.

Or rather, they don't accept it again unless you're a member of the "official friends club".

These sellers are allowed to send repeated lots over and over again, even if they don't sell, and they always put them back up for auction with a reserve price. Why? It's very simple:

Catawiki experts receive a bonus on top of their salary if they list more lots than their monthly target.

In other words, the system rewards experts for quantity, not for results or quality. I know this for a fact.

What ends up happening? Experts tend to accept lots only from sellers who offer items in bulk—auction galleries, antique dealers, or resellers of items from house clearances.

This way, they get a lot of work done at once and can easily reach the quota of lots needed to receive that bonus at the end of the month. The team led by Heiko Neitzel puts this into practice with complete impunity, and the "expert" Carmen Iñiguez Berbeira accepts lots that have already been offered time and time again—from, for example, these sellers:

 https://www.catawiki.com/es/u/2425667-subastabcn

 https://www.catawiki.com/es/u/22563611-pictura-subastas

 https://www.catawiki.com/es/u/23463889-pictura-galeria

There are many others, of course.

I suppose that being an expert in a field, and never actually getting to smell or touch a lot with your own hands, makes you ultimately indifferent to this kind of work. It must be a naturally assimilated apathy born out of frustration, I suppose.

To me, this kind of behavior seems as unprofessional as can be, and if it were up to me, I'd fire this team of "experts" immediately. I don't think they can do their jobs with any interest or honesty anymore.

The platform's credibility is certainly plummeting—if it has any left at all—and I would be very grateful if one of these experts had the guts to reply to this post and refute my claims.

u/Regular-Sell-8192 — 7 days ago

When I've bought pieces knowing they were fake, it's been with the UTTER INTENTION of later filing a claim and being able to report the case. You shouldn't do that without physical proof. Some "artists" can't fool anyone anymore because of that.

Of course I know how modern digital art production works. Don't try to give it that air of mysticism. Le Yack's images are created in seconds, simply by slightly modifying a prompt; any AI can generate 12 images in a flash! There's no layering, refinement, or anything like that you're trying to make me believe!

I have nothing against AI. I even think it can produce wonderful things, but I can't stand those clowns who use it and proclaim themselves ARTISTS and scam people into believing they're buying that valuable "mixed media" and "hand-signed" art. "

Real art is a bit like studying the graphology of a handwritten text. You can't hide the writer's personality; it's always there... an artist always leaves that trace of personality, style... you always see "his ways". And Le Yack's images—and many others—as a whole, lack any coherence that reflects the will, style, or personality of a real artist. It's like a Saturday flea market: "Come in, look around, and choose! We always have something for everyone!..."

I know the technology he uses very well, believe me, and I can even give you a prompt and tell you which platform to use, so you can upload it and it will generate tons of fantastic images. Then you ask it to increase the resolution and voila! But you don't even need to do that, if you are tired and don't want to write or struggle yourself with the keyboard... You upload any image and ask the AI ​​for variations. And that's it! 12 variations in 15 seconds!

You can upload those images to Catawiki immediately! The AI ​​also creates those images of fake rooms with the painting hanging on the wall, as if it really existed... Oh! do not forget to include that silly photos of wourself holding that cheap brush beside a canvas and smiling stupidly to camera...! there's no need to print anything. You spend nothing. You risk nothing. Only if the poster sells, then you print it —that's what it is, a poster, nothing more— , and of course, sometimes you're delayed with shipping because you have to print and mount it on the frame... In the rush, you end up stretching the canvas incorrectly, and buyers complain... have you seen the negative reviews about Le Yack on Catawiki?

But you're right about one thing: Many artists don't start with a drawing and "attack" the brushstroke and color directly. True. But there's still a process behind it. And it can -and must-be shown. That's it! The PROCESS! Not the POSES!

What I'm saying is that in Le Yack's Giclée prints there's no human hand involved except for the signature, which is indeed "hand-signed." Ohhh... what a piece of art...!

reddit.com
u/Regular-Sell-8192 — 19 days ago

Where is Le Yack now?

A few days ago, the "artist" selling on Catawiki called Le Yack responded to some of my posts where I said that his "original art" was simply AI-generated images.

 He says no, that he is an artist who works with both conventional techniques and digital painting, etc. His gallery on Catawiki:

 https://www.catawiki.com/es/u/19080511-galerie-le-yack-leyack

I say that's not true. They are AI-generated images that he sometimes retouches with a few strokes of paint. How am I so sure? Just look at his gallery. How can you have 30 or 40 "complex" pieces up for auction at the same time?

 He says he works full-time. Even so. Furthermore, there are a number of telltale signs that allow you to deduce when a gallery is created by AI and not by a real artist:

- A suspiciously high number of pieces

- A ridiculous and excessive variety of styles (there is no personal style; it's all a jumble of nonsense without coherence or sense)

- An exhibition of filler "selfie" photos that attempt to justify the unjustifiable (people looking at paintings in a gallery, the "artist" holding a paintbrush as if it were a pencil and a child's palette a foot away from the artwork, and smiling at the camera with complicity, etc.)

- A lack of images of the artwork's process

- A lack of photos showing real detail, where the brushstrokes and textures are clearly visible.

 In short… I challenged him, in response to his complaint, to delight us with his art and skill by posting some photos of the process of one of his works—initial sketch, sketch on the canvas, intermediate stages, and finished piece—but it seems he now has nothing to say. He's not responding.

My request isn't unreasonable or expensive. Simply put, as he paints a new piece, he needs to take some photos. Simple and cheap. But now the artist is saying nothing. In my region, we have a saying: "Silence gives consent."

u/Regular-Sell-8192 — 22 days ago