u/Powerful-Mix-8592

Why was the Ming so bad at war? And how did they last that long?

Of the major Imperial Chinese dynasties like Han, Tang, Song, Yuan, etc. the Ming seemed to have been the most blessed when it came to their enemies. While other dynasties had to face very potent nomadic empires (Xiongnu, Khitan Liao, Jurchen Jin, Mongol themselves), strong state opponents (Gorguyeo, Abbasid, Western powers like the British and the French), and major peasants rebellions (the Yellow Turban, the Red Turban, the Taiping), the Ming faced none of the above. The Nomads they faced were weak (the Yuan being reduced to the rump state of North Yuan), their state opponents weren't that strong when compared to others (the Japanese in the Imjin war, while potent, was not as overpowering to them as the later British/French), and they didn't face major peasant rebellion until Li Zhicheng.

And yet, they got their butts spanked, bad. Their emperor was captured at Tumu, their army was bogged down in Korea, their entire coast had to be evacuated as they could not deal with piracy. The Song dynasty, widely considered to be a disgrace to China, fought off the Liao, the Jin, and the Mongols for a hundred year; the Yuan, a foreign empire in a majority Chinese country, fought off environmental calamities and peasant uprising for a solid twenty years before collapsing; the Qing survived 70 years since the beginning of the Opium war through multiple defeats and humiliation. And there the Ming was, collapsing in a mere fifty years.

So, why were the Ming so bad?

reddit.com
u/Powerful-Mix-8592 — 8 hours ago

Looking for book suggestions for my peculiar taste

Hi all,

Going through some stuff at work these days and I want to de-stress with reading some fantasy novels. I do, however, have some peculiar taste in my novel. When it comes to novels, the things I like are

-Third person point of view (somehow first person irks me)

-Prose wise, I like the prose in a similar vein to First Law, The Dagger and The Coin, The Dark Profit. I don't like Scott Bakker's prose (too dense), Sanderson's (too bland), Robert Jordan's, and Gavriel Kay's (it just slides off me)

-I like out of the box, non-traditional storyline, where your main cast breaks every mold there is and the story goes way you never expect it to go. That's why I don't like Red Rising or Dune - you can see where the story is going from ten miles away. Some grim dark is nice, but I do like witty funny story.

-I am a fan of big battle. Pellenor field, battle of the Hero, the many battles waged in Mary Gentle's Ash. Caveat: it has to be well-researched and at least made some sense. Also I don't like battles where the main character single-handedly win it, especially done so with magics or deux ex machina (looking at the Poppy war and the Boys who became the sun duology)

-Bonus point if the story is non-European inspired fantasy, but if it is something other than European then at least be something that is well-researched: I was put off by the Lotus war series because of its research into Japanese culture is narrow at best.

So, anyone has suggestions?

reddit.com
u/Powerful-Mix-8592 — 1 day ago
▲ 8 r/army

Clarification on Chapter 5-14

Hi,

So one of my soldiers came to me in mental distress, and as much as I encourage the SM to go to Behavorial health the SM said the SM did not want to go to Behavorial health for fear of Chapter 5-14, which, the SM claimed, would meant the SM would be expelled from the army under a "Other than honorable discharge" and the SM was afraid it would mean an end to the SM's career.

I am trying to get more information on case like this, and have been getting some mixed result. Some told me that if an SM was discharged on mental issues ground, it would be an honorable discharge. Some told me, however, it could easily become a Chapter 5-14 and the SM would be discharged as "other than honorable" with a stain on their record, making them unemployable in the future.

My question is

1- If a soldier in good moral standing, is a solid soldier, has no issues with the law or chain of command, is discharged for mental issues, will it be a honorable discharge or not?

2- When is it a Chapter 5-14 discharge? And when is it another case?

3- When will such procedures be enacted? At what point will the army look at and say, "Yes, this guy is wrecked. We will get him out of the army"

reddit.com
u/Powerful-Mix-8592 — 1 day ago