u/Key_Bison_9322
I am talking about acerbic criticism, not soft ball criticism
I arrived in Shanghai 10 years ago thinking it was spectacular but unfinished; after comparing it with NYC, Paris, Hong Kong, Singapore, and Tokyo, my view has changed: Shanghai may now be the strongest total urban package I know.
The city keeps adding real urban quality: Suzhou Creek regeneration, the 45km Huangpu riverfront, FFC street life, West Bund museums/galleries, Qiantan Taikoo Li, North Bund redevelopment, Shanghai Library East, Museum of Art Pudong, PSA, Fotografiska, Shanghai Museum East ...
The industrial mix is also impressive: Lujiazui finance, Zhangjiang semiconductors and biomedicine, AI firms like MiniMax and SenseTime, consumer internet/media like Xiaohongshu, Bilibili and miHoYo, plus Tesla and advanced manufacturing in Lingang ...
Do other long-term expats who have lived in top-tier cities also feel Shanghai has moved from “impressive Chinese megacity” to one of the world’s best overall urban experiences?