u/Key-Banana8924

I'm playing Fable Anniversary. Was able to fish fine on my Xbox 360. Got an Xbox X a couple weeks ago and now I have no control of reeling. It's like it automatically constantly reels for me. If I never press X, it makes the reeling sound but never fails or catches.

If I press X once, then the progress bar appears, reeling sound continues, and it does actually auto-reel constantantly until I lose the fish. Even without touching X again.

Any ideas?