Beginner headaches: can sharpen my chisels okayish but the Stanley #4 plane? That remains unusable
Hating the plane I'm trying so hard to love. Bought it 2nd hand and posted here earlier - with the large consensus being I was probably not sharpening well.
So I bought a jig, which happened to include an angle guide for good measure.
went at it again, this Time with the jig from 400 grit upwards - If anything, I somehow made it blunter. Couldn't seem to generate a burr, or somehow it's too fine for me to feel? don't know.
After almost crying I tried sharpening my 1" (25mm) chisel for the first time (haven't used my chisel set yet and after the plane sharpening attempts over the past few months I didn't have the heart to try) - did it freehand because I felt I could feel the bevel and stay consistent.
Massive difference : I could definitely feel a burr, I could definitely clear on next sandpaper. I don't have a strop yet so I just went up to 2500 grit for the sake of testing the chisel. It works! Not paper thin shavings but likely because I used too small a wood to test it quickly, and I probably do need to strop to get to a better sharpening quality, but at least the tool was sharper than it started.
Is there something I'm missing with plane irons? Are they just harder to do and this is normal rookie struggles? Hard to not give up on the plane!