u/HeinzBeanBoy

I love this sub but I think i have a different view on Swampy to some people. I feel like his best stories are the hopeless ones (early American Gothic, Alan Moore/ Batman 23 & Winter Special, Tom King).

Swamp Thing is effectively a god and i feel the best stories are the ones with a believable reason why he'd lose which have to be things outside his control (ie hopeless).

I'm curious as to what other people think are necessary for peak Swamp Thing stories.

I'm aware my opinion could be seen as pessimistic but I'll die on the hill that the depressing ones are the best stories.

reddit.com
u/HeinzBeanBoy — 12 days ago