In Season 5 (and actually already at the end of Season 4), we see that Gilead has supporters and even followers in Canada.
During the trial of Fred and Serena Waterford, and later at Fred’s funeral, Gilead gains a lot of support from some Canadians, also thanks to Serena’s influence.
Then Lawrence creates “New Bethlehem” and promises forgiveness for American refugees in Canada who want to return to a more “human” version of Gilead. It even feels like some countries are starting to open up to Gilead again.
What feels less believable to me is that all of this suddenly disappears after Boston is liberated.
It’s like all the Gilead supporters suddenly vanished or lost all their influence in Canada. Sure, there’s still the “Pearl Girls” program to attract young girls to Gilead, but overall it feels like Gilead suddenly lost a lot of influence.
That part felt a bit unrealistic to me.