I (28F) need advice to ask SIL (33F) for my shirt back?
I (28F) have been dating my boyfriend(28M) for almost 8 years. His family is very different from mine, and his sister (33F) is a clepto. Without getting into too much detail she had/has drug related mental issues. I used to live with them for about three years, and it seemed like my stuff was always fair game. We both like anime/manga, and i had an extensive library that she would often go in. I even once ran into her while she was taking at least a dozen books, and as i stare at her in disbelief, she unbothered says “oh, do you mind if i borrow these?”. I said sure in utter shock, knowing that i would never see those books again. Because of her disposition ive honestly chalked all this up as a loss… but heres the main issue at hand:
I had an instagram artist ive been in love with since at least 2014. When they released a limited clothing line i was first to buy before they sold out. I was over the moon to finally have not only a physical work but it was so cute and worked well with so many different outfits, i was in love.
And then it was stolen. I knew she took it. It had been missing for years. I reached out to the artist last year and asked if theyd ever make the shirt again. They said unfortunately for the time being they wouldnt have clothes in their shop for a long while (its already been 8 years 😭😭😭) . I was devastated. Not only could i not replace it, but i couldnt even buy a piece to replace it…
The kicker? We go over yesterday evening to his parents. Shes sitting there in a zipped up jacket but it took me less then a second to recognize it. Peaking out from under the zipped jacket i could see the hand from the design. She still had it. She didnt lose it. Thank god!!!! But now my whole issue- how do i go about asking for MY shirt back? Im so relieved she still has it but i dont even know how to go about mentioning, “Hey i saw you wearing my shirt, can i have it back?”. Its so awkward, im so un-confrontational, but i want it back so bad. It took everything in me not to blow up at her yesterday.
So, how do i go about asking for my shirt back without sounding like a jerk???
Thank you in advance!