I’m deciding between two GS 350 options and want some honest input, especially from people with experience owning or working on these cars.
Option 1: $17k • 2016 GS 350 F Sport • ~78k miles • Salvage title • CARFAX shows moderate damage + total loss (non-collision), front and rear damage, vehicle was towed • 1 owner, good service history
Option 2: 19k • 2015 GS 350 Crafted Line • ~99k miles • Clean title, 2 owners, good service history
I prefer the body style of the 2016 model. Also not the biggest fan of the red interior in the Crafted Line but I could deal with it.
Does a salvage GS 350 (with that type of damage history) realistically become a reliability risk over time, even if it’s been repaired well? Is the mileage difference even meaningful on these cars, or am I overvaluing that?
I’m trying to make a smart long-term decision, not just chase the “better deal” upfront.
Appreciate any real-world insight.