I am hoping to be a Storyteller in the future and I’d like some advice for dealing with character abilities that have “may” or “might” in the wording.
I understand that it is Storyteller’s discretion, but do experienced Storytellers have some additional recommendations? I also understand that if one team seems to be winning give information or do something that benefits the underdogs.
But if there is no clear direction, what do you do? For example, if the Demon targets the Mayor, does the Mayor die only 25% of the time? Or 50%? Or does the Mayor only die in the rare cases where the evil team is struggling?
Other common instances are for poisoning. You may give right or wrong information to a poisoned player. But do you give the wrong information almost always? Or do you keep it random?