Alright, I feel like I’m losing my mind at this point.
Setup:
PS5 → HDMI → Elgato 4K X → PC (OBS)
Chat Link Pro → controller + headset
What works:
Video in OBS = perfect
Audio over HDMI (before Chat Link) = perfect
What breaks everything:
The SECOND I plug in the Chat Link Pro/headset…
OBS goes completely silent
Video still fine
I can hear everything in my headset
So clearly PS5 is rerouting audio to the controller and killing HDMI audio. Cool. Got it.
Here’s where it gets stupid:
Every single tutorial says:
“Just switch from HDMI audio to Analog audio in Elgato software”
…except…
I DON’T HAVE THAT OPTION ANYWHERE
I’ve:
Installed Elgato software
Checked OBS properties
Closed every app that could be using the capture card
Restarted everything like 10 times
Nothing.
No analog toggle. No hidden setting. Nothing.
So now I’m stuck in this loop:
No Chat Link → OBS audio works
Chat Link plugged in → OBS audio dies
“Fix” requires analog option
Analog option does not exist
Amazing.