u/Drama_Cookie25

Like the only good part is the horror. It is the most scary poppy playtime game. The nightmare scene is amazing, and the designs for catnap and ms delight are great. Plus the atmosphere is really good. But besides that it kinda is mid.

The gameplay is boring. It’s way worse than 5. At least in 5 all the puzzles are different. Here so many puzzles are so repetitive. And there are way more puzzles then in 5 and no they aren’t spaced better. Home sweet home and the councilor office are just puzzles. Ms delights section while having an enemy is still just a puzzle. And then there’s all the cave puzzles. Plus the catnap boss fight is awful.

Like besides the boss fights it’s really boring, the mini critter section is not fun. There’s also a lot of walking.

Also while I did like catnap being more of a threat behind your back, there was so little of him.

And while the story it added was good, the characters were all flat.

Also I don’t know why people think the animation is better than 5, there are tons of glitches and errors. The only error I’ve seen in 5 was huggy holding a non existent wall.

Like I have my issues with 5, the first third is really boring, though fixed lilys chase is still bad, and there isn’t much horror, it’s still better. At least unlike 4 it had an unsettling factor again, being ms Gracie. It also was fun besides the first third with characters who weren’t one dimensional. And the prototype boss fight (yeah it’s not a chase it’s a boss fight) was actually fun to do.

To be clear I’m not saying chapter 3 is bad. If I were to rank chapters it’s my second favorite, with 5 in front (total ranking would be 5 3 4 2 1 project playtime Roblox games). I’m just saying it’s not as good as people said. People are like “this was the best mascot horror game ever and all the other chapters are horrible” and that’s really not true. It’s good but not that good.

https://preview.redd.it/sld7hv5rgmug1.png?width=686&format=png&auto=webp&s=4a39ce9399346ad6b8ccb804eac6a7b1a7cfd51b

She got stabbed in the brain, and even if not very deep she lost a lot of the blood. The shot of her on the floor bleeding out shows her eyes open and unblinking. She's not in a coma she's just dead. LIKE SHE WAS WEARING A WHITE DRESS, the moment i saw her in that i knew she's dead. And this makes sense writing wise, fisk is going to go absolutely insane and crazy with Vanessa dead. This is great writing. I mean we saw what he did in another universe she dies in (cough cough into the spiderverse cough cough). So yeah she's dead.

I mean we’ve seen how powerful they are. Golden cheese can make buildings from sand. Hollyberry is able to fight and survive and sorta win against DRAGONS. Dark cacao was able to survive stormbringer and not die from heavensplitter. And there’s more examples.

So while legendaries are obviously more powerful, maybe soul jam is just more powerful then we thought. Burning spice destroyed countless civilizations, mystic flour could turn a world into flour, and shadow milk has insane magic and a whole team. So beasts and ancients are probably very close in power to the legendaries. (Though not close to millennial tree, sugar swan, or timekeeper).

With that said, shadow milk now has 4 soul jam. And in addition to that the powers of the ultimate cookies, who even sugar swan said if let out of the oven everyone would be doomed, who would absorb all of earth bread. So is it unreasonable to think that shadow milk can now at the very least survive and fight against timekeeper? I don’t think it is.

Timekeeper is still probably more powerful, but knowing her she probably is going to let shadow milk do some chaos for entertainment

(And no it’s not milking him considering he’s always been the main beast before he became popular, and before the beasts were a thing. This was planned in 2017. Also by the logic he’s being milked then pure vanilla is too).

Also no shadow milk will not be overshadowing timekeeper. Did stardust overshadow moonlight? Smoked cheese overshadow golden cheese? Albalone overshadow black pearl? No they didn’t.