l've played all the mafia games a couple times over. (Played them all last year in anticipation for this game). Just got around to playing and I loved it. The knife system and fighting is awesome. The charms were an extremely nice touch that I wish we had something like in Mafia 1 and 2.
The game is beautiful graphically and artistically. The gunplay felt good, the driving is so good and the horses weren't too shabby either. (Even tho No Tommy gun at that time unfortunately). I like the low-key street signs (the dynamic direction ones) this game compared to the past ones. My one complaint is the "blue body bins" Either get rid of them entirely or make them different things that make sense in the area.
Only thing that isn't better than the other games in the series is the music and you can't get cops to chase you in this.