u/Dazzling_Childhood_4

I was going to get a neverfull for my first Louis, and I do like the concept of it. But I see so many awful replicas of it that it’s put me off a little. Out of these 2 which would you go for?

Or if anyone has any suggestions, I like a bigger bag ideally shoulder. And as much as I like the speedy it’s just not my style nowadays.