I’m exploring an idea and wanted honest feedback from both players and server owners/devs (especially in FiveM).
The idea is NOT a global ban list.
It’s more of a shared RP identity + whitelist system that could include:
For players:
- Create a character profile (name, backstory, traits, etc.)
- Save multiple characters
- Apply to multiple servers using one profile
- Track applications
- Potential tools like:
- Character creator assistant (e.g. slider suggestions based on a selfie)
- RP helper tools (scenarios, prompts, guides etc.)
For server owners:
- Centralised whitelist applications
- Player profiles (instead of long forms)
- Notes / incident logs (with evidence)
- Optional cross-server “signals” (not hard bans, just shared info)
- Appeals system
- API integration for servers
The goal is:
Make it easier for players to get into servers, and reduce admin workload for staff.
Questions:
Players:
- Would you actually use something like this, or prefer starting fresh on each server?
- What would make you trust (or not trust) a system like this?
- Would you care about having a persistent RP “identity/profile”?
Server owners/devs:
- Would you use a system like this or keep everything internal?
- What would make this a hard no?
- What feature would make it immediately useful?
Everyone:
- What’s the most frustrating part of RP onboarding right now?
Not selling anything - just trying to figure out if this solves a real problem or not.