I’ve seen a lot of people wondering why he would choose an inflatable pool to commit the dismemberment because he used a chainsaw, but here’s why I think it made sense in his mind.
First, I believe people might be confusing the inflatable pool with a small kiddie pool, but some inflatable pools are actually fairly large.
So, let’s try to put ourselves in his situation at the time. He’s 5’5” and 125 lbs. Reasonably fit, but small in stature. Celeste was 5’2”, weight unknown, but she was 71 pounds when her body was discovered. Given the state of decompression she was in, I’d assume she weighed significantly more when she was alive and at the time of her dismemberment.
Also keep in mind that she had allegedly been deceased for about two weeks before he committed the dismemberment. By this time, the rigor mortis stage has dissipated and the body has become flexible again. Depending on the exact date of the dismemberment and the conditions her body were stored in, she would have been either at the end of the bloating stage, entering the active decay stage or fully into active decay.
Even for a strong person who’s 5’5” and 125 lbs, it would still be reasonably difficult to move a deceased person around that’s only slightly smaller than they are. Even just getting a good grip on a deceased person who’s completely limp and decomposing is going to be challenging.
So why the inflatable pool? Well, I think it made sense in his mind for two reasons.
- Obviously, he wanted to contain the blood, tissue and bone fragments that would result from the chainsaw dismemberment. If it was a large enough inflatable pool, it may have been big enough to catch most of the tissue, blood and bone fragments that resulted from the chainsaw dismemberment.
As long as he didn’t angle the bar of the chainsaw down more than say 45 degrees as he cut, he likely would have been able to contain most of that overspray of blood, tissue and bone fragments, reducing the mess as much as possible in his mind.
- Given how difficult it would have been for him to move her body around, I believe the inflatable pool helped solve that problem as well. Rather than having to pick her up off of the ground and lift her above a ledge to get her into a plastic kiddies pool, it would have been easier for him to spread the pool out on the floor, drag the body of Celeste into the center, then inflate the pool once she’s already in the center. At that point, he could start the dismemberment process, believing he was containing the mess. Or trying as best he could, at least.
Once the dismemberment was complete, he could put the dismembered parts of Celeste’s body in the cadaver and trash bags, soak up the blood and fluids with towels, blankets, old clothes or something else, clean up any excess tissue or large bone fragments to the best of his ability, deflate the pool, roll it up and dispose of it the best he could.
Of course, the authorities would still find traces of DNA even after a good cleanup in this situation, but for a person who is likely panicked, in a rush and just needs to figure out something to with a body as quickly as they could, I think it probably made sense in his mind.
In addition to that, the authorities would also find fragments of blue plastic in the cut wounds of Celeste, likely from the teeth of the chainsaw hitting the bottom of the inflatable pool as he was cutting through Celeste’s body.