u/Botched_Lemon

Since its implementation in the 1990s, mounting research has shown it promotes self-sufficiency and keeps people housed. Housing First is 88% more effective at curbing homelessness than Treatment First.

About 98% of people enrolled in Permanent Supportive Housing stay in their homes one year after being housed, according to the National Alliance to End Homelessness.

However, the current HUD administration wants to walk away from the model.

The thinking is that people should have to get treatment before qualifying for housing. I'm sure not all housing-first participants succeed, especially those who suffer from substance abuse, mental illness or other health issues. But is it truly housing first that is to blame, or are people not getting proper treatment after they are housed?

I know these issues vary by region, so I'd value a nuanced analysis on some of the benefits and shortfalls of housing first in your area.

u/Botched_Lemon — 11 days ago

Florida Highway Patrol troopers drew their guns and ordered Deanne Rollison out of her car and onto the ground. Over their shouting and a barking K-9, Rollison could hear her 6-year-old daughter crying from the back seat.

Troopers had mistaken her 2019 Toyota Camry for a 2016 Toyota Corolla involved in a shooting in Columbia County that day in July 2024 — though the car model and occupants did not match the suspect's description, court records show.

A dozen law enforcement vehicles, some from other agencies, swarmed the scene.

“I feared my daughter might make any movement,” she said. “I was afraid they’d kill my baby.” 

Rollison said she thinks she was stopped simply because she is Black, since that is the only detail she said matched the suspect's description. She is not alone in that belief.

FHP troopers stopped and searched Black drivers more often than White drivers, and found drugs, weapons and other contraband in Black drivers' cars less often than in White drivers' cars, according to a TCPalm data analysis of over 1 million FHP traffic stops from 2024-25.

https://www.tcpalm.com/story/news/local/florida/2026/04/22/do-florida-fhp-stats-show-black-racial-bias-over-whites-discrimination-civil-rights-profiling/89630451007/

reddit.com
u/Botched_Lemon — 11 days ago

One family struggles to find housing in one of Florida's wealthiest counties while parenting a child with cerebral palsy. Gabby King and Dorsey DuBois are homeless in Martin County along with their 13-year-old daughter, Aleah.

The family has tried everything from Section 8 to camping, but just can't catch a break.

They're in line for Permenant Supportive Housing, but that's still in the works.

This is the first part of a series following their journey from homelessness back to home again.

tcpalm.com
u/Botched_Lemon — 11 days ago