Should we care what socialists say?
Hear me out.
I've noticed a pattern when discussing with socialists.
They will present an idea like "We just need to have a dictatorship that will redistribute all the wealth!"
And the rebuttal will be like "But whenever this has been tried it ends very poorly."
And the socialist responds like "But we say it will be amazing!"
Does it matter what socialist say? Does it matter what anyone says? Why not prioritise facts in instead of sayings?
Why shouldn't we look at history to see how poorly the promises of socialists ended up?
Socialists love to live in capitalist countries. Drinking their soy lates and avocado toasts. Meanwhlie socialists don't want to live in socialist countries. How can we trust you? Seriously.
This is a bit of a tangent, but if I really believed in socialism I would go live in a socialist country.
I don't find it believable that socialists really believe what they say because they don't practice what they preach. So why should any of us care about what socialists say?
EDIT:
I should specify. I do think it's totally valid to care about what socialists do. Socialists cause a lot of problems. So I think it can be fruitful to engage with socialists on that end. But if socialists do X and say Y I care about X and not Y.