OP: https://www.reddit.com/r/richmondbc/s/jYY8qIp12s
Thanks to the commenters who correctly identified it as Pick One. Shortly after posting it and looking into them, it started showing up in my algorithm and I decided to drop in for their organized game night on Thursday and had a good time.
I'm in my late 30s so I was definitely on the older side of the crowd. Most of the ~30-40 attendants were probably in their early to mid 20s and seemed to be more into playing higher player count party games so it may not be for everyone. That said, I started at a casual table and had a good time playing some casual rounds of Flip 7 and then heard another table looking for players to play Tyrants of the Underdark. It wasn't my favorite game but scratched my itch to play something a bit heavier before switching gears to play some Wavelength and Jungle Speed.
The place has a good selection of games. Like my shelf at home, a lot of games are still in shrink but are available to play. I think they've been open for three months and doing organized Thursday game nights for two. At $10, I'll definitely drop in again from time to time to scratch that itch when I'm not able to set up a home game.
I don't know which flair works so I guess consider this a PSA for a new local business that caters to a very specific niche?