Need advice: Better financial decision between under-construction 2.5BHK vs near-ready 3BHK in Pune?
I’m confused between two properties and want objective financial advice from people who have bought homes recently.
My profile:
Salary: ~₹2 lakh/month
Existing liabilities:
Home loan EMI: ₹30k/month (only ~₹6L principal remaining, ends around 2028)
Car loan EMI: ₹30k/month (ends next year)
Current savings/liquid cash: ~₹22L
Already own a 2BHK flat in Wagholi
If I move to the new flat, I can rent Wagholi flat for around ₹20k/month
Option 1: Kamdhenu The Astria
2.5BHK
900 carpet
8th floor
Amenity facing
Price: ~₹87L
Possession verbally committed around 2028, RERA 2030
Construction-linked plan:
10% booking now
20% + govt charges in July
10% on plinth in Dec
then smaller 5% slab-wise demands
Plan is to take only ~₹30L home loan and self-fund remaining payments gradually from salary/savings
Option 2: Joyville Celestia
3BHK
936 carpet
2nd floor
Price: ~₹1.01Cr
Builder possession next year, RERA Dec next year
Need to pay ~95% quickly
Would likely need ~₹75–80L loan
My analysis so far:
Astria = much lower interest cost and lower risk/stress, but money gets locked for 3 years and possession delayed
Joyville = much higher EMI initially, but near-ready property, can shift earlier, rent out Wagholi flat, and possibly better long-term asset quality
Questions:
From purely financial perspective, which is smarter over next 5–10 years?
Is taking a bigger loan actually better here because of inflation + keeping my own capital liquid?
Is under-construction risk worth saving on interest?
Would you personally choose lower leverage or near-ready larger township?
Does the small carpet difference (900 vs 936) make the 3BHK premium worth it?
Would appreciate practical advice from people who have gone through similar decisions.