The greatest magician in the world was a Columbus runaway—and we’ve mostly forgotten him.
Most people can name local icons like R.L. Stine or Jack Nicklaus, but in the 1920s, the most famous man on the planet was a kid from Columbus named Howard Thurston.
His obsession started right here in 1876. When he was just 7 years old, he watched the legendary Alexander Herrmann perform at the Grand Opera House on High St., and it changed his life forever. He eventually ran away at 13 to follow that dream, eventually becoming the world’s leading illusionist.
When he was at the height of his fame, he would return to the city as a conquering hero to perform his "Wonder Show of the Universe" at the Hartman Theater (which used to stand at State and Third). His shows were so massive they required dedicated train cars just to haul the illusions and animals into downtown.
I’ve been fascinated by his story since I stumbled upon Thurston for an escape room project I was researching back in 2023. It struck me as odd that there isn't a major landmark for a guy who quite literally "made magic" for the world. (At least I don't know of one unless we consider his entombment at Columbus' Green Lawn Abbey mausoleum.) Howard Thurston's story inspired me to create an immersive experience on Gay St. designed to feel like the 1920s world he lived in (Magician's Secret).
Does anyone else have some great stories from Columbus' history? I’m looking for more stories about the old theaters or forgotten local legends. I'm sure our city has a wild history hidden in plain sight, and I’d love to hear what else you've found.